New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Balanced Budget Amendment

Thank you for this (frankly rather wordy) admission to the group that you were using completely worthless measurements of government in your (false) argument that government has gotten "smaller."

As you know, I admitted no such thing. Instead, I pointed out why it would be foolish not to factor population into an assessment of government size. I assume you already understood that to be foolish, so I'm curious why you've pretended otherwise.

As for your last point, government has been growing faster than GDP since 2000

You're getting federal spending and government spending confused again. Do you have the government spending data?
 
As you know, I admitted no such thing. Instead, I pointed out why it would be foolish not to factor population into an assessment of government size. I assume you already understood that to be foolish, so I'm curious why you've pretended otherwise.



You're getting federal spending and government spending confused again. Do you have the government spending data?

You said it makes sense to assume economies of scale but you have no idea how to calculate it, so you decided to use the more misleading per capita measure anyway. I think we can all agree that this was a self serving decision that supports your point, and you chose to use it despite the fact that you admit it is not appropriate. The appropriate measure is (obviously) to compare (real) total spending and assume in the absence of reasonable indications that the government should NOT be expected to incur economies of scale to offset any population growth in excess of real spending growth this is a correct and true indicator of the size of government. That measure doesn't support your (false) assertion that government has "shrunk" on Obama's watch, which is (obviously) why you went with the more misleading number.

Either or, it doesn't matter - they both support my point and disprove yours...
 
You said it makes sense to assume economies of scale but you have no idea how to calculate it, so you decided to use the more misleading per capita measure anyway

No. You may wish to reread. I think it does make sense that there would be economies of scale, but as between your method (assuming no government growth needed to address population growth), and my method (assuming proportional growth is needed), the latter is quite clearly less misleading. That's especially true given the fact that, as I pointed out, the per-GDP analysis might be superior to each, and would tend to show even less government growth in proportion than the per-GDP analysis shows. Ideally, we'd come up with some sort of hybrid per-GDP/per-capita index, which would then be modified by an assumed economy of scale. If you want to propose something of that sort, it might be worth looking into. However, since the per-capita analysis comes down roughly where I'd expect that hybrid/adjusted index to come out, and would not differ in any way that matters for purposes of the point I was arguing (that government spending has been growing over the last century), that's more of an academic consideration at this point.

That measure doesn't support your (false) assertion that government has "shrunk" on Obama's watch

Again, my point is simply that the counter-trend in the Obama years doesn't erase the fact that the overall trend of the last century has been of government spending growth. If you want to argue there hasn't even been a counter-trend in the Obama years, but rather just a slowing of the prior trend, once we apply whatever "economy of scale" data manipulation you've pulled out of the air, that's certainly possible. Once we open the door to you adjusting the data based on no standards but whatever you've invented off the top of your head, I'm sure the trend can be whatever you'd like it to be. But, I wasn't comfortable just inventing some number off the top of my head, that way. Instead, I expressed what my standard was, in a clear and forthright way: Total government spending on a real per capita basis. Using that standard, government has shrunk on Obama's watch, but not enough to change the overall long-term trend of government growth.
 
No. You may wish to reread. I think it does make sense that there would be economies of scale, but as between your method (assuming no government growth needed to address population growth), and my method (assuming proportional growth is needed), the latter is quite clearly less misleading. That's especially true given the fact that, as I pointed out, the per-GDP analysis might be superior to each, and would tend to show even less government growth in proportion than the per-GDP analysis shows. Ideally, we'd come up with some sort of hybrid per-GDP/per-capita index, which would then be modified by an assumed economy of scale. If you want to propose something of that sort, it might be worth looking into. However, since the per-capita analysis comes down roughly where I'd expect that hybrid/adjusted index to come out, and would not differ in any way that matters for purposes of the point I was arguing (that government spending has been growing over the last century), that's more of an academic consideration at this point.



Again, my point is simply that the counter-trend in the Obama years doesn't erase the fact that the overall trend of the last century has been of government spending growth. If you want to argue there hasn't even been a counter-trend in the Obama years, but rather just a slowing of the prior trend, once we apply whatever "economy of scale" data manipulation you've pulled out of the air, that's certainly possible. Once we open the door to you adjusting the data based on no standards but whatever you've invented off the top of your head, I'm sure the trend can be whatever you'd like it to be. But, I wasn't comfortable just inventing some number off the top of my head, that way. Instead, I expressed what my standard was, in a clear and forthright way: Total government spending on a real per capita basis. Using that standard, government has shrunk on Obama's watch, but not enough to change the overall long-term trend of government growth.

Maybe YOU should "reread." I never said "no growth" is needed to address population growth - I simply said it's safe to assume whatever you lose in growth per capita is likely to be (or should be expected to be) offset by economies of scale. Yours is not only clearly MORE misleading, in that you admit there should be economies of scale occurring, but you prefer the "boost" you get in "justifiable" growth of government by pretending it can't be estimated so that it must then be irrelevant. I'll grant you that per GDP might have some significance, but then, as I showed, it has grown as a percent of GDP more or less steadily since the end of WWII, which corresponds to a period marked by slowing (YoY) GDP growth rates (indicating that your assertion that growth in government somehow drives growth in prosperity is, of course, preposterous).

And then, after all this, you make another half hearted appeal to use your perverted "real per capita" measure, and then go on to repeat the already denuded argument that government has "shrunk on Obama's watch" by again attempting the false claim that the TEMPORARY "stimulus" spending was a "permanent" growth in government. This is getting tiresome...
 
Maybe YOU should "reread." I never said "no growth" is needed to address population growth - I simply said it's safe to assume whatever you lose in growth per capita is likely to be (or should be expected to be) offset by economies of scale.

I have no idea what you're trying to say, at this point. My point is pretty simple. As a country grows in population, we would expect the size of the government to grow, too, to keep up the same amount of services per capita. In the Obama era, the combined forces of inflation and population growth have outpaced government spending growth, resulting in a proportionally smaller government. However, that relative shrinkage has not been anywhere near enough to change the big-picture fact that government has been growing over the last century. And that government growth, over the past century, has coincided with major improvements in general prosperity.
 
I have no idea what you're trying to say, at this point. My point is pretty simple. As a country grows in population, we would expect the size of the government to grow, too, to keep up the same amount of services per capita. In the Obama era, the combined forces of inflation and population growth have outpaced government spending growth, resulting in a proportionally smaller government. However, that relative shrinkage has not been anywhere near enough to change the big-picture fact that government has been growing over the last century. And that government growth, over the past century, has coincided with major improvements in general prosperity.

And it's also wrong. As the population has grown, the size of government HAS grown, too. The only way you should expect it to grow in concert with population growth is if you admit that government is so incompetent that it simply cannot find any economies of scale to implement (which then disqualifies your entire argument that government should be given even more to do, as well as that it is somehow integral to increasing prosperity).
 
Given the possibility of a Constitutional Convention to pass a balanced budget amendment, would you favor it?

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_..._teaming_up_to_call_a_new_constitutional.html

For me, it comes down to the details. I think it's a popular idea among conservatives because they see it stacking the deck in favor of their own vision of a small, weak government. Basically, pass popular tax cuts and then, when the columns don't add up, automatic spending cuts kick in, even if the cuts are unpopular enough that they'd never have passed democratically.

However, it would be theoretically possible to set the idea up to stack the deck in the opposite direction. Instead of automatic spending cuts kicking in to bring spending down to revenues, automatic tax hikes could kick in to bring revenues up to spending. Understandably, the conservatives wouldn't like this, because liberals could use it to bring about larger, stronger government: pass popular spending programs, then when the columns don't add up, automatic tax increases kick in, even if these increases are unpopular enough that they'd never have passed democratically.

In theory, you could middle-ground it. In the event of a mismatch between revenues and spending, automatic spending cuts and automatic tax hikes both kick in, designed to meet half-way. That way the amendment could not be used to stack the deck either way -- there'd be a genuinely democratic fight about the proper size and role of government.

Another issue is how you deal with situations where a deficit really is needed. For example, what about wartime? Should we really discipline ourselves with "pay as you go" during a war? We'd never have won independence or survived the war of 1812 or preserved the union with that rule. If we're unable to borrow and adversaries are, we're at a distinct disadvantage. Yet, you wouldn't want wars that aren't existential threats to create a blank checkbook. We blew trillions of dollars on a dumb whim in Iraq, and a little fiscal discipline to steer us away from that mistake would have been nice.

Standard economic theory also argues you should run a deficit during recessions and the first part of recoveries, and then offset that by running surpluses in other times. And demographic bulges can create situations where you might want to borrow in some periods and run surpluses in others. Special buying opportunities also would justify borrowing (e.g., to finance the Louisiana Purchase or the purchase of Alaska), and so could other investments that would create long-term returns.

One idea to deal with all this would be some sort of super-majority voting rules allowing for deficits and surpluses. But, that keeps it a highly politicized matter. You might instead create a mechanism for some nonpartisan group, insulated from day-to-day politics, to set the yearly deficit or surplus based on various factors, similar to how the Fed sets money supply. However, given the way right-wing heads explode when Fed control of money supply is mentioned, I doubt that will be a popular idea.

What do others here think?

No. Government needs flexibility, whether it's a national emergency, natural disaster, war or a giant rock from space............
 
And it's also wrong. As the population has grown, the size of government HAS grown, too. The only way you should expect it to grow in concert with population growth is if you admit that government is so incompetent that it simply cannot find any economies of scale to implement (which then disqualifies your entire argument that government should be given even more to do, as well as that it is somehow integral to increasing prosperity).

As of 2013 , there were 3,007 counties, 64 parishes, 19 organized boroughs, 11 census areas, 41 independent cities, and the District of Columbia for a total of 3,143 counties and county-equivalents in the United States.

One of the arguments is contradictory.

One way to find an economy of scale is to stop acting as if we are 50 independent nations. Then...every independent nation is comprised of a number of independent sub-nations. Most States call them counties...Louisiana calls them parishes. 3,143 little governments, all trying to be sovereign...and run their own show.

So...Maryland has 24 school boards...24 Police Forces, 24 this's and 24 that's. Right there, one can see room for economy of scale. However...the result is more centralized government. This is the basic problem...to achieve economies of scale, the first tier government would gain greater authority over these smaller governments...

Call it Walmart Government...
 
As of 2013 , there were 3,007 counties, 64 parishes, 19 organized boroughs, 11 census areas, 41 independent cities, and the District of Columbia for a total of 3,143 counties and county-equivalents in the United States.

One of the arguments is contradictory.

One way to find an economy of scale is to stop acting as if we are 50 independent nations. Then...every independent nation is comprised of a number of independent sub-nations. Most States call them counties...Louisiana calls them parishes. 3,143 little governments, all trying to be sovereign...and run their own show.

So...Maryland has 24 school boards...24 Police Forces, 24 this's and 24 that's. Right there, one can see room for economy of scale. However...the result is more centralized government. This is the basic problem...to achieve economies of scale, the first tier government would gain greater authority over these smaller governments...

Call it Walmart Government...

Or, the federales could devolve management of programs to the states, like the founding fathers envisaged...

http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/1982/01/why-block-grants-work

That's a wordy discussion, and if I had to sum it up I'd say the reason they work is that the states have to compete with one another (to an extent). Citizens are free to relocate to states that do a better job of spending tax dollars. When it is centralized at the federal level we're captive subjects with no recourse if the feds blow dough on unproductive, inefficient and incompetent (not to mention fraud riddled) operations. Sort of the "anti-economy of scale economy of scale." If the federal government had a competitor, you'd see it implementing economies of scale. It doesn't, which is the reason we don't. I'm all for municipal mergers but as for the concept that a centralized government would be more efficient, count me a skeptic.
 
Last edited:
Or, the federales could devolve management of programs to the states, like the founding fathers envisaged...

http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/1982/01/why-block-grants-work

That's a wordy discussion, and if I had to sum it up I'd say the reason they work is that the states have to compete with one another (to an extent). Citizens are free to relocate to states that do a better job of spending tax dollars. When it is centralized at the federal level we're captive subjects with no recourse if the feds blow dough on unproductive, inefficient and incompetent (not to mention fraud riddled) operations. Sort of the "anti-economy of scale economy of scale." If the federal government had a competitor, you'd see it implementing economies of scale. It doesn't, which is the reason we don't. I', all for municipal mergers but as for the concept that a centralized government would be more efficient, count me a skeptic.

Reagan?

We already established that the idea he shrank government was false.

The block grants obviously do nothing to alleviate the issue of 3,143 little governments vying for control...and offering duplicate services.
 
Reagan?

We already established that the idea he shrank government was false.

The block grants obviously do nothing to alleviate the issue of 3,143 little governments vying for control...and offering duplicate services.

No we did not. We established that his record on that was mixed. Yes deficits went up but a lot of it was investment in military assets. As with infrastructure investments, borrowing to fund investment is often a good, economically sustainable idea. Borrowing to pay social welfare entitlements? Not so much.

And actually, they do - as the most efficient states will be the ones who get that sh*t under control. And the most efficient states win the battle for population growth. This isn't rocket science...
 
No we did not. We established that his record on that was mixed. Yes deficits went up but a lot of it was investment in military assets. As with infrastructure investments, borrowing to fund investment is often a good, economically sustainable idea. Borrowing to pay social welfare entitlements? Not so much.

And actually, they do - as the most efficient states will be the ones who get that sh*t under control. And the most efficient states win the battle for population growth. This isn't rocket science...

Yes...we did. Mixed? He grew government. He grew debt. Any other conclusion is mendacious.

So...California is the most efficient state in the union?
 

The west and south continue to lead growth patterns...and that has been going on for a long time. California remains, by far, the state with the greatest population.

Now...you're faced with the idea that the southern states are the most efficient. Can you make that argument?
 
I don't believe that addresses the question.

Differences between states also reflect bureaucratic
efficiencies. For example, while D.C. and Louisiana have
deep-seated problems of waste and corruption, New
Hampshire is known for its more effective government.
Some states, such as Alaska and New Mexico, have high
levels of bureaucracy across many budget areas. Other
states, such as Pennsylvania and Rhode Island, have
consistently lower levels of bureaucracy.
Table 3 shows the states with the biggest and smallest
bureaucracies in each budget area. The top states have two
or more times the relative number of government workers
as the bottom states. It is not clear that the top states get
any benefit from bigger government. As one example, my
statistical analysis showed that there is no correlation
between K-12 employment and SAT scores by state.
One conclusion is that there seems to be substantial
room for increased government efficiency in many states.
Although this bulletin provides only a brief look at
differences in state bureaucracy, the data indicate that
some states deliver government services with many fewer
workers than do other jurisdictions.


http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/tbb-0601-29.pdf
 
Differences between states also reflect bureaucratic
efficiencies. For example, while D.C. and Louisiana have
deep-seated problems of waste and corruption, New
Hampshire is known for its more effective government.
Some states, such as Alaska and New Mexico, have high
levels of bureaucracy across many budget areas. Other
states, such as Pennsylvania and Rhode Island, have
consistently lower levels of bureaucracy.
Table 3 shows the states with the biggest and smallest
bureaucracies in each budget area. The top states have two
or more times the relative number of government workers
as the bottom states. It is not clear that the top states get
any benefit from bigger government. As one example, my
statistical analysis showed that there is no correlation
between K-12 employment and SAT scores by state.
One conclusion is that there seems to be substantial
room for increased government efficiency in many states.
Although this bulletin provides only a brief look at
differences in state bureaucracy, the data indicate that
some states deliver government services with many fewer
workers than do other jurisdictions.


http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/tbb-0601-29.pdf

Awesome. Thanks for contradicting your claims.
 
Simply because its fair.

There are people today living off other people. Yes/No? That is not fair. A flat tax is fair, no one can argue different. You can argue it won't work but you can't argue it isn't fair.
Build a Tributary to a Flowing Channel From a Useless Lake

Fairness is for fairies. The phony Limousine Liberals purposely take money from the idle rich and give it to the idle poor, always excluding those who can make better use of the money than either group of parasites.
 
Back
Top