KnotaFrayed
Mayor
what does this have to do with anything?
who does any common criminal represent?
We're talking about improvised explosive devices and "guerilla" status based on not representing a nation, but possibly some "militarized" grouping, no? Would you like to deny that before 9/11, McVeigh's improvised explosive device was the WORST terrorist act on U.S. soil? Did we round up McVeigh and his Militia Movement pals and send them to GITMO and deny them any sort of justice or suggest they should be denied protection under the Geneva Convention because they set off an IED as "guerillas" in their own nation in an act of terrorism?
Would you suggest that Americans should be hauled off to someplace like GITMO if they plant IED's that target foreign military troops who have invaded their nation?
Was it okay for Mujahideen (supported by the U.S. CIA) to fight Soviet troops who had invaded their nation (Afghanistan) in the 80's? What changed from then other than we became the invading military force? Did we really expect all the people of other nations would welcome our military incursions into their nations without shooing at us? Would you be cheering on the incursion of a foreign nation's military into our nation or would you be shooting at them? Do you know what the Vichy French refers to? Were they patriots or traitors to the French people? Have you ever thought about why it is important to seriously consider military incursions into other nations to go after "common criminals", most of which haven't killed as many Americans as Timothy McVeigh killed or amount to the same sort of threat to Americans as America's own homicide rate?
Read what John Qunicy Adams said in a 4th of July speech in 1821:
http://millercenter.org/president/speeches/detail/3484
In addition, think about what terrorists use to recruit people against the U.S. and whether our actions do more to give them ammunition and feed the fires or deprive them of ammunition and extinguish the fires?