GITMO is a necessary evil.
People are getting tripped up on the detention of the prisoners there without "due process" without examining whether or not there is evidence that the prisoners are being held a punishment for crimes. They are not. It is not a crime to be at war with the United States, and their detention is not criminal punishment -- it is wartime detention no different than the POWs that the U.S. has held without due process in other wars, from the standpoint of criminal evidence.
The difference lies, of course, in that in essentially every other international conflict in which the U.S. has been engaged we were fighting the uniformed forces of other nation states -- some of which had signed and agreed to fight under the rules set by the Hague Accords, the Geneva Conventions, and other laws of land warfare. Terrorists wage war without a nation state, outside of uniform and without signing or agreeing to follow the laws of land warfare. As a result, they fall into a gray area in both U.S. and international law. They aren't POWs, with the full rights of POWs, because they haven't signed the Geneva Convention and do not themselves follow its rules. They aren't, as already stated, criminals, because it isn't against the law for them to conduct acts of war. The law is insufficiently evolved to deal with people who are, at the end of the day, members of hostile NGOs.
But the detention is done not to punish them for violations of the law, but to prevent them from returning to the fray. I see no scheme for releasing them that would keep that from happening.
People are getting tripped up on the detention of the prisoners there without "due process" without examining whether or not there is evidence that the prisoners are being held a punishment for crimes. They are not. It is not a crime to be at war with the United States, and their detention is not criminal punishment -- it is wartime detention no different than the POWs that the U.S. has held without due process in other wars, from the standpoint of criminal evidence.
The difference lies, of course, in that in essentially every other international conflict in which the U.S. has been engaged we were fighting the uniformed forces of other nation states -- some of which had signed and agreed to fight under the rules set by the Hague Accords, the Geneva Conventions, and other laws of land warfare. Terrorists wage war without a nation state, outside of uniform and without signing or agreeing to follow the laws of land warfare. As a result, they fall into a gray area in both U.S. and international law. They aren't POWs, with the full rights of POWs, because they haven't signed the Geneva Convention and do not themselves follow its rules. They aren't, as already stated, criminals, because it isn't against the law for them to conduct acts of war. The law is insufficiently evolved to deal with people who are, at the end of the day, members of hostile NGOs.
But the detention is done not to punish them for violations of the law, but to prevent them from returning to the fray. I see no scheme for releasing them that would keep that from happening.