New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

it's time to close GITMO

GITMO is a necessary evil.

People are getting tripped up on the detention of the prisoners there without "due process" without examining whether or not there is evidence that the prisoners are being held a punishment for crimes. They are not. It is not a crime to be at war with the United States, and their detention is not criminal punishment -- it is wartime detention no different than the POWs that the U.S. has held without due process in other wars, from the standpoint of criminal evidence.

The difference lies, of course, in that in essentially every other international conflict in which the U.S. has been engaged we were fighting the uniformed forces of other nation states -- some of which had signed and agreed to fight under the rules set by the Hague Accords, the Geneva Conventions, and other laws of land warfare. Terrorists wage war without a nation state, outside of uniform and without signing or agreeing to follow the laws of land warfare. As a result, they fall into a gray area in both U.S. and international law. They aren't POWs, with the full rights of POWs, because they haven't signed the Geneva Convention and do not themselves follow its rules. They aren't, as already stated, criminals, because it isn't against the law for them to conduct acts of war. The law is insufficiently evolved to deal with people who are, at the end of the day, members of hostile NGOs.

But the detention is done not to punish them for violations of the law, but to prevent them from returning to the fray. I see no scheme for releasing them that would keep that from happening.
 
GITMO is a necessary evil.

People are getting tripped up on the detention of the prisoners there without "due process" without examining whether or not there is evidence that the prisoners are being held a punishment for crimes. They are not. It is not a crime to be at war with the United States, and their detention is not criminal punishment -- it is wartime detention no different than the POWs that the U.S. has held without due process in other wars, from the standpoint of criminal evidence.

The difference lies, of course, in that in essentially every other international conflict in which the U.S. has been engaged we were fighting the uniformed forces of other nation states -- some of which had signed and agreed to fight under the rules set by the Hague Accords, the Geneva Conventions, and other laws of land warfare. Terrorists wage war without a nation state, outside of uniform and without signing or agreeing to follow the laws of land warfare. As a result, they fall into a gray area in both U.S. and international law. They aren't POWs, with the full rights of POWs, because they haven't signed the Geneva Convention and do not themselves follow its rules. They aren't, as already stated, criminals, because it isn't against the law for them to conduct acts of war. The law is insufficiently evolved to deal with people who are, at the end of the day, members of hostile NGOs.

But the detention is done not to punish them for violations of the law, but to prevent them from returning to the fray. I see no scheme for releasing them that would keep that from happening.

I wish I had written this. Very well said. Since the Obama narrative is that we're not at war with radical islamic jihadists, it's easy I suppose for his supporters to get caught up in the 'civil rights' aspect of this 'law enforcement' issue.

I'm all for treating them like human beings when they start acting the part.

on a purely emotional level I find it difficult to conjure up sympathy for those that target the innocent.

Our constitution was never meant to be a death sentence and if the Bush administration created Gitmo as a means to avoid having these mooks covered by it's protections, then I salute them
 
I'm one of the shallow ones who wants our SYMBOL of torture/war crimes torn down......as a first step.

It's only shallow if you stop there. It would be a bit like Germany tearing down Auschwitz, because it was particularly central symbol of the Holocaust, while keeping other work and death camps in place for "undesirables."

Heck, we'd do better to take a lesson from Germany (and South Africa, and so many others with a shameful past," and NOT tear down Gitmo. Instead, preserve it perfectly, so that future generations can tour it as a reminder of man's capacity for inhumanity towards his fellow man. Take those in Gitmo and give them proper trials -- freeing them or sending them to real prisons depending on the outcome -- then set Gitmo up the way Robben Island in South Africa or Auschwitz is set up, with tours and displays memorializing the crimes against humanity we committed there.
 
actually, i've been in favor of closing gitmo for years.

i don't think there's any point in bringing the detainees "stateside". we're not in a position to conduct real trials, due to the extraordinary lapse of time, and the clandestine/covert nature of the evidence against them.

i say release them all back to any country where charges are stil pending. if they are not wanted elsewhere, they get free airfare and pocket money back to their country of citizenship.

for real
 
actually, i've been in favor of closing gitmo for years.

i don't think there's any point in bringing the detainees "stateside". we're not in a position to conduct real trials, due to the extraordinary lapse of time, and the clandestine/covert nature of the evidence against them.

i say release them all back to any country where charges are stil pending. if they are not wanted elsewhere, they get free airfare and pocket money back to their country of citizenship.

for real

http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/03/06/us-usa-guantanamo-recidivism-idUSTRE82501120120306

can we do that on the same day we pass feinstein's 'gun control' law.

I want the irony to be complete
 
GITMO is a necessary evil.

People are getting tripped up on the detention of the prisoners there without "due process" without examining whether or not there is evidence that the prisoners are being held a punishment for crimes. They are not. It is not a crime to be at war with the United States, and their detention is not criminal punishment -- it is wartime detention no different than the POWs that the U.S. has held without due process in other wars, from the standpoint of criminal evidence.

The difference lies, of course, in that in essentially every other international conflict in which the U.S. has been engaged we were fighting the uniformed forces of other nation states -- some of which had signed and agreed to fight under the rules set by the Hague Accords, the Geneva Conventions, and other laws of land warfare. Terrorists wage war without a nation state, outside of uniform and without signing or agreeing to follow the laws of land warfare. As a result, they fall into a gray area in both U.S. and international law. They aren't POWs, with the full rights of POWs, because they haven't signed the Geneva Convention and do not themselves follow its rules. They aren't, as already stated, criminals, because it isn't against the law for them to conduct acts of war. The law is insufficiently evolved to deal with people who are, at the end of the day, members of hostile NGOs.

But the detention is done not to punish them for violations of the law, but to prevent them from returning to the fray. I see no scheme for releasing them that would keep that from happening.

Those captured making war on the US can be held as POWs --and afforded all the legal protections the Geneva Conventions give POWs. That's not the issue. The issue is what's happening at Gitmo to those who were captured far from any battlefield, not bearing arms, not wearing uniforms, not clearly affiliated with any organization at war with the US, and held in a legal black hole that is not subject to either civil law or the laws governing POWs.

Take as a real-world example the case of Lakhdar Boumediene. He was an Algierian-born Bosnian citizen and charity worker, wrongly accused of plotting an attack on the US Embassy in Sarajevo. He was tried by a Bosnian court, which legally determined there was no evidence against them, and ordered him to be released. US military personnel then kidnapped him from Bosnia, and shipped him off to Guantanamo Bay, where he was tortured and kept from his family for seven long years, without even the right to challenge his captivity in court. Finally, in 2008, the Supreme Court ordered the Bush administration to make its case against him, in a Habeas Corpus proceeding (an ancient right, long-predating the Constitution, which Bush had decided not longer existed). When he finally got his day in court --even a military tribunal with all the cards stacked against him-- Boumediene again showed what he'd already showed all those years earlier in Bosnia: that there was no evidence against him. So, he was finally released, and today lives in France, where he suffers from the aftermath of his years of abuse, and from the long disruption to his family.

Boumediene wasn't a POW. He'd never joined any military, he'd never carried arms against the US, and he'd never gone anywhere near our battlefields in Iraq and Afghanistan. He was an unlucky guy who got swept up in a bit of bad police work and then, despite a judge ordering him to be released, spent the better part of a decade imprisoned by an lawless American regime. And he's one of the LUCKY ones. Some of our detainees died before they got their day in court, and others were completely broken men by the time they were released. And yet all have been denied the ability to sue for the injustice done to them. It's a national disgrace that will follow us down through history. And it's a huge gift to the ACTUAL terrorists, who can point with glee to the way we treat Muslims.
 
Those captured making war on the US can be held as POWs --and afforded all the legal protections the Geneva Conventions give POWs. That's not the issue. The issue is what's happening at Gitmo to those who were captured far from any battlefield, not bearing arms, not wearing uniforms, not clearly affiliated with any organization at war with the US, and held in a legal black hole that is not subject to either civil law or the laws governing POWs.

The Geneva Convention does not generally extend its protection to non-signatories, or for that matter to non-uniformed troops. There is a circa-1979 codicil that extends POW status to members of "spontaneous militias" so long as they separate themselves from the surrounding population and agree to obey the rules of the Geneva Convention. Terrorists such as these do not do this -- a moot point as the U.S. rejected that codicil.

As for those found on the battlefield in Afghanistan, at one point we had combat-status review tribunals, but they were roundly criticized by liberals taking the best sorting mechanism out of action.
Take as a real-world example the case of Lakhdar Boumediene. He was an Algierian-born Bosnian citizen and charity worker, wrongly accused of plotting an attack on the US Embassy in Sarajevo. He was tried by a Bosnian court, which legally determined there was no evidence against them, and ordered him to be released. US military personnel then kidnapped him from Bosnia, and shipped him off to Guantanamo Bay, where he was tortured and kept from his family for seven long years, without even the right to challenge his captivity in court. Finally, in 2008, the Supreme Court ordered the Bush administration to make its case against him, in a Habeas Corpus proceeding (an ancient right, long-predating the Constitution, which Bush had decided not longer existed). When he finally got his day in court --even a military tribunal with all the cards stacked against him-- Boumediene again showed what he'd already showed all those years earlier in Bosnia: that there was no evidence against him.

Well, there are problems with this account, not the least of which is you are again calling for criminal evidence and rules of habeas where no crime has been alleged. I also see bias, or at least ignorance, in the statement that a military tribunal was necessarily "stacked against" him. In a court martial/military tribunal, the same rules of evidence apply that apply in courts -- where there is an allegation of criminal activity.

So, he was finally released, and today lives in France, where he suffers from the aftermath of his years of abuse, and from the long disruption to his family.

It's a tragic example, I agree -- but does it generally describe most GITMO detainees? I think there's fair reason to doubt that. And what do you do to ensure that those who actually are terrorists and enemies of the U.S. do not return to their warmaking activities when they are released? If these had the rights of POWs, they'd be released at the end of hosilities. Have hostilities ended?
 
actually, i've been in favor of closing gitmo for years.

i don't think there's any point in bringing the detainees "stateside". we're not in a position to conduct real trials, due to the extraordinary lapse of time, and the clandestine/covert nature of the evidence against them.

i say release them all back to any country where charges are stil pending. if they are not wanted elsewhere, they get free airfare and pocket money back to their country of citizenship.

for real

I'll go with that.
 
Be accountable for what we did. Bring the detainees here for trial or let them go. It cannot be any worse than holding them for another 5 or 10 years in limbo and at least it will send the message that at least some Americans recognize the injustice and our hypocrisy and want to do something to make amends for it and live up to our claims of what we stand for?

What would you suggest? Delaying closure on the whole sorry affair longer? If people begin to die in GITMO because of our delay in living up to our beliefs about justice and being accountable for our own actions, what do people believe that will do to our security? I am most certain it will not improve it, nor increase trust or belief in the U.S. as a champion of justice and freedom and likely those that die will become martyrs of sorts and held up for a long time as reminders of the mess GITMO has become for our credibility and interest in justice and living up to our beliefs.

Looking back to what Knot said., he and Arkady have brought up some very good points.
 
The Geneva Convention does not generally extend its protection to non-signatories, or for that matter to non-uniformed troops. There is a circa-1979 codicil that extends POW status to members of "spontaneous militias" so long as they separate themselves from the surrounding population and agree to obey the rules of the Geneva Convention. Terrorists such as these do not do this -- a moot point as the U.S. rejected that codicil.

As for those found on the battlefield in Afghanistan, at one point we had combat-status review tribunals, but they were roundly criticized by liberals taking the best sorting mechanism out of action.


Well, there are problems with this account, not the least of which is you are again calling for criminal evidence and rules of habeas where no crime has been alleged. I also see bias, or at least ignorance, in the statement that a military tribunal was necessarily "stacked against" him. In a court martial/military tribunal, the same rules of evidence apply that apply in courts -- where there is an allegation of criminal activity.



It's a tragic example, I agree -- but does it generally describe most GITMO detainees? I think there's fair reason to doubt that. And what do you do to ensure that those who actually are terrorists and enemies of the U.S. do not return to their warmaking activities when they are released? If these had the rights of POWs, they'd be released at the end of hosilities. Have hostilities ended?

It sounds like, in your worldview, the president could lock up ANYBODY, ANYWHERE, ANYTIME subject to no rules on his discretion, governed by no law, criminal or POW, simply by asserting they are enemy combatants, and keep them locked up as long as he wants. If you're comfortable with rendering the Constitution, habeas corpus, and international law functionally meaningless like that, that's where you and I differ.

In a court martial/military tribunal, the same rules of evidence apply that apply in courts -- where there is an allegation of criminal activity.

If the same rules applied as applied in other courts, there'd be no reason to have courts martial or military tribunals. The whole idea is that rules differ -- not least among which is the CONSTITUTIONALLY GUARANTEED RIGHT TO A JURY OF YOUR PEERS. Boumediene was a civilian, and ought to have been given a civilian trial. Yet, despite his rights having been violated on that front, he was still ordered to be released.
Anyway:
http://www.cnn.com/2007/LAW/01/18/detainee.trials/
 
It sounds like, in your worldview, the president could lock up ANYBODY, ANYWHERE, ANYTIME subject to no rules on his discretion, governed by no law, criminal or POW, simply by asserting they are enemy combatants, and keep them locked up as long as he wants. If you're comfortable with rendering the Constitution, habeas corpus, and international law functionally meaningless like that, that's where you and I differ.

No, but the president could indeed detain those captured by U.S. troops in the field, who have gone through three separate screening before being permanently detained -- which describes most of those in GITMO today -- and they could be detained through the end of hostilities.



If the same rules applied as applied in other courts, there'd be no reason to have courts martial or military tribunals. The whole idea is that rules differ -- not least among which is the CONSTITUTIONALLY GUARANTEED RIGHT TO A JURY OF YOUR PEERS. Boumediene was a civilian, and ought to have been given a civilian trial. Yet, despite his rights having been violated on that front, he was still ordered to be released.

The difference between civil courts and courts martial have nothing to do with evidentiary procedures. A person tried by a military tribunal is no entering a kangaroo court. Boumodiene is one example of a generally reliable system failing to work, and as I said, a tragic example. And if Boumodiene was actually engaged in acts of war against the United States, he should have been held as a prisoner of war and not tried at all.

And no, we are not entitled to a trial by a jury of our peers, and indeed the Supreme Court has ruled that there is no such thing as a jury of ones peers.
 
The Geneva Convention does not generally extend its protection to non-signatories, or for that matter to non-uniformed troops. There is a circa-1979 codicil that extends POW status to members of "spontaneous militias" so long as they separate themselves from the surrounding population and agree to obey the rules of the Geneva Convention. Terrorists such as these do not do this -- a moot point as the U.S. rejected that codicil.

As for those found on the battlefield in Afghanistan, at one point we had combat-status review tribunals, but they were roundly criticized by liberals taking the best sorting mechanism out of action.


Well, there are problems with this account, not the least of which is you are again calling for criminal evidence and rules of habeas where no crime has been alleged. I also see bias, or at least ignorance, in the statement that a military tribunal was necessarily "stacked against" him. In a court martial/military tribunal, the same rules of evidence apply that apply in courts -- where there is an allegation of criminal activity.



It's a tragic example, I agree -- but does it generally describe most GITMO detainees? I think there's fair reason to doubt that. And what do you do to ensure that those who actually are terrorists and enemies of the U.S. do not return to their warmaking activities when they are released? If these had the rights of POWs, they'd be released at the end of hosilities. Have hostilities ended?

a significant % will
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/03/06/us-usa-guantanamo-recidivism-idUSTRE82501120120306
 

"Recidivism" is a misnomer, in this case. Recidivism is a relapse into crime. Relapse can only take place if the person was a criminal to start. In the case of those being released from Gitmo, it's generally because they were never proven to have committed a crime in the first place. Thus, they can't be recidivists. If they were innocent people who became radicalized through many years of torture and confinement in the company of hardened jihadis, and decided to take revenge on their captors when released, that's not recidivism.

It is, however, a big problem. Picture yourself in those shoes. Picture you're an innocent, captured, denied a trial for decades, kept in harsh confinement, humiliated, tortured, kept from even speaking to your family until you've missed your kids's childhoods, and only then, after a decade of lost time, are you released when your captors have to admit they had no evidence to support your imprisonment. Imagine, once freed, you suffer from PTSD, from being water-boarded and threatened for years, and you have trouble holding down a job. Your life is in shambles. Imagine you're denied any compensation for all those years stolen from you, or even a chance to know who provided false accusations against you. Wouldn't it be awfully tempting to take to a battlefield to exact your revenge?
 
"Recidivism" is a misnomer, in this case. Recidivism is a relapse into crime. Relapse can only take place if the person was a criminal to start. In the case of those being released from Gitmo, it's generally because they were never proven to have committed a crime in the first place. Thus, they can't be recidivists. If they were innocent people who became radicalized through many years of torture and confinement in the company of hardened jihadis, and decided to take revenge on their captors when released, that's not recidivism.

It is, however, a big problem. Picture yourself in those shoes. Picture you're an innocent, captured, denied a trial for decades, kept in harsh confinement, humiliated, tortured, kept from even speaking to your family until you've missed your kids's childhoods, and only then, after a decade of lost time, are you released when your captors have to admit they had no evidence to support your imprisonment. Imagine, once freed, you suffer from PTSD, from being water-boarded and threatened for years, and you have trouble holding down a job. Your life is in shambles. Imagine you're denied any compensation for all those years stolen from you, or even a chance to know who provided false accusations against you. Wouldn't it be awfully tempting to take to a battlefield to exact your revenge?

hmm... no mention of reparations... you goin' soft?

choose whatever term you like. bad guys go back and do harm to others once let out of the brig.

enable them any way you like.
 
"Recidivism" is a misnomer, in this case. Recidivism is a relapse into crime. Relapse can only take place if the person was a criminal to start. In the case of those being released from Gitmo, it's generally because they were never proven to have committed a crime in the first place. Thus, they can't be recidivists. If they were innocent people who became radicalized through many years of torture and confinement in the company of hardened jihadis, and decided to take revenge on their captors when released, that's not recidivism.

Hans Guderian was a famous German general during WWII who helped develop the doctrine of mobile warfare later termed "blitzkreig." He surrendered to U.S. troops in 1945, and was held until the war had been over for three years, ultimately released in 1948. What crime had he committed to be held for that three year period? What "due process" was skipped?


It is, however, a big problem. Picture yourself in those shoes. Picture you're an innocent, captured, denied a trial for decades, kept in harsh confinement, humiliated, tortured, kept from even speaking to your family until you've missed your kids's childhoods, and only then, after a decade of lost time, are you released when your captors have to admit they had no evidence to support your imprisonment.

What evidence is needed if the person is not a criminal, but merely someone who has declared themselve at war with the United States? Imagine the consequences of returning membes of Al Qaeda and the Taliban to the world to continue their activities.
 
Time for the US Military to leave Guantanamo....It has No business there...The Cuban people do not want them there....Shut it down and give back to Cuba
 
The difference lies, of course, in that in essentially every other international conflict in which the U.S. has been engaged we were fighting the uniformed forces of other nation states -- some of which had signed and agreed to fight under the rules set by the Hague Accords, the Geneva Conventions, and other laws of land warfare. Terrorists wage war without a nation state, outside of uniform and without signing or agreeing to follow the laws of land warfare. As a result, they fall into a gray area in both U.S. and international law. They aren't POWs, with the full rights of POWs, because they haven't signed the Geneva Convention and do not themselves follow its rules. They aren't, as already stated, criminals, because it isn't against the law for them to conduct acts of war.

The other difference is that in certain other conflicts (e.g., WWII), the U.S. Congress had acted in its constitutional capacity to declare war ... whereas today, the U.S. is not in the midst of any declared war. In fact, while the U.S. is fighting against al-Qaeda in Afghanistan and Iraq, it is allied with al-Qaeda in Syria. Murder, attempted murder, battery, etc., are in fact crimes and the accused could be treated as accused criminals.

Cuba has faced a more consistent and ongoing campaign of terrorism than any other country in the world. It has never imprisoned or killed a terrorist suspect without at least a summary trial, and in most cases a full criminal trial. It has never retaliated with violence of its own against the country sponsoring the terror (usually the United States), but instead has followed the grievance procedures set up by the UN (something that the U.S., with its political power, could do much more effectively than Cuba has). It has released some of its imprisoned terrorists, both for humanitarian reasons and as part of negotiations with the U.S., and it has suffered further terrorist attacks as a result; but the alternative would be abandoning the rule of law, which Cuba is unwilling to do.
 
Hans Guderian was a famous German general during WWII who helped develop the doctrine of mobile warfare later termed "blitzkreig." He surrendered to U.S. troops in 1945, and was held until the war had been over for three years, ultimately released in 1948. What crime had he committed to be held for that three year period? What "due process" was skipped?




What evidence is needed if the person is not a criminal, but merely someone who has declared themselve at war with the United States? Imagine the consequences of returning membes of Al Qaeda and the Taliban to the world to continue their activities.

If we're talking about a general in a military of a nation-state with which we're at war, then we're in agreement. For example, any Iraqi generals we captured during that war could be held as prisoners of war until the end of those hostilities. But that's not relevant to a discussion of what we can do to people who merely get labeled "enemy combatants," despite, quite often, having been captured far from any war zone, and despite having never been members of any military with which we are at war. If we allow the precedents of POW treatment to apply to anyone the president, in his unreviewable personal discretion, has labeled an "enemy combatant," that swallows up every Constitutional right you and I have. At that point, our rights can be erased on the whim of one man.
 
The other difference is that in certain other conflicts (e.g., WWII), the U.S. Congress had acted in its constitutional capacity to declare war ... whereas today, the U.S. is not in the midst of any declared war. In fact, while the U.S. is fighting against al-Qaeda in Afghanistan and Iraq, it is allied with al-Qaeda in Syria. Murder, attempted murder, battery, etc., are in fact crimes and the accused could be treated as accused criminals.

Not that I think that this will come to pass, but if either of the two most recent presidents were ever brought to trial over their use of troops sans a declaration of war, I would expect both of them to point to the AUMF as a de facto declaration of war. A moot point, as Congress doesn't have to declare war for the Commander in Chief to employ the U.S. military. The Constitution sets no such requirement.

Cuba has faced a more consistent and ongoing campaign of terrorism than any other country in the world.

Really? I can document more than 1000 attacks on U.S. targets, at home and abroad, just by Islamic terrorists since 1970. Cuba has had more? I find that hard to believe.

It has never imprisoned or killed a terrorist suspect without at least a summary trial, and in most cases a full criminal trial.

Outright lie. Che Guevara did summary executions with a baseball bat once Fidel Castro assumed power.

It has never retaliated with violence of its own against the country sponsoring the terror (usually the United States), but instead has followed the grievance procedures set up by the UN (something that the U.S., with its political power, could do much more effectively than Cuba has). It has released some of its imprisoned terrorists, both for humanitarian reasons and as part of negotiations with the U.S., and it has suffered further terrorist attacks as a result; but the alternative would be abandoning the rule of law, which Cuba is unwilling to do.

Wow.
 
Back
Top