New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Non-partisan question

Nope. Neither am I one to glom onto war propaganda simply because my side happened to win the war. There was plenty of immorality to go around in the 1860s.

THAT makes me wonder if you even read the rest of my post. I never said, BTW, that the North didn't engage in any acts of 'immorality' during the war. But I will persist in regarding the Civil War as essentially a contest between good and evil, right and wrong. If that bothers you, you're just going to have to live with it. As I said, I had several ancestors who died in that war. They were all fighting on the Union side. And they all believed they were fighting to free the slaves. We have the letters they wrote home to prove that. There's a reason for those words in "The Battle Hymn of the Republic".....
 
None of which alters the fact that the Confederate soldiers were fighting for a dishonorable cause. I think the Vietnam War was a terrible mistake, but would not go so far as to say that our soldiers in Vietnam were fighting for a dishonorable cause.

i would
 
BS Degs, the tone we are experiencing now is all democrat created and fostered.
Right..
that's because the Dems were the ones who attacked the Speaker of the House on bogus charges (Gingrich vs. Oneill)

That's because the Dems issued a memo telling the Dem rank and file to frame Republicans as "Unpatriotic", "Socialist", "Dangerous", "weak" etc.

That's because the Dems engaged in a historically unprecendentd Filibuster of an elected POTUS in 1992.

That's because the Dems forced a Government shut down in the mid 1990s to "prove that the Federal Government isn't necessary"

That's becuase the Dems used their daddies appointments to the Supreme Court to violate the Majority electorate (and Majority of the EC) and bypass a recount in FL

That's because the Dems engaged in DOUBLE the filibuster of that unelected POTUS in the first year of the first black president

That's Because the Democratic voters admitted in 2008 to having AT LEAST 15% of their voters voting based on racism..


UHUH.. Sorry Color. EVERY ONE OF THOSE is due to the GOP. Every fvcking one of those.
 
THAT makes me wonder if you even read the rest of my post. I never said, BTW, that the North didn't engage in any acts of 'immorality' during the war. But I will persist in regarding the Civil War as essentially a contest between good and evil, right and wrong. If that bothers you, you're just going to have to live with it. As I said, I had several ancestors who died in that war. They were all fighting on the Union side. And they all believed they were fighting to free the slaves. We have the letters they wrote home to prove that. There's a reason for those words in "The Battle Hymn of the Republic".....

Doesn't bother me if it helps you sleep at night. I lost ancestors in that war as well -- on both sides.
 
I hope you're not one of the people that drive around with a Confederate flag in the back of your pickup truck, NS. Our soldiers in Vietnam BELIEVED they were fighting to save those South Vietnamese peasants from falling under a terrible Communist tyranny. Which, of course, is exactly what happened after we declared victory and got the hell out. But it was still all wrong, because those soldiers were misinformed by our leadership of that era. Ho Chi Minh was never a committed Marxist. He was a nationalist, who simply wanted nothing more than for Vietnam to be united. In that sense, he was sort of like Lincoln! We drove him into the arms of the Communists.

I hope you don't try to give me any lectures on Vietnam. I did not speak with my father, and he did not speak with me, for the last six months of his life, because we strenuously disagreed on the Vietnam War. I had told him that I would be a conscientious objector, or would even flee to Canada. He was the old-fashioned sort who thought our government could do no wrong. Except for Spiro Agnew, whom my father loathed. To this day, I regret that my father and I parted on such very poor terms, that we could not even speak to each other.

actually ho was a communist long before america came onto the scene.
 
I do sleep very well at night, thank you. But I sometimes do wonder how defenders of the Old Confederacy can.

Am I defending the Confederacy?

Wars are always started as a quest for political and economic power. They only become great moral struggles in retrospect -- after they have been won.
 
There are two categories of vets. The ones who got there early on thought it was an honorable cause. We had just announced that we would be standing down when I got there. Like Kerry said, "Who wants to be the last one to die in a war that we've already given up on?" (Paraphrased) By 1970, we knew better than to think there was some lofty goal. Success was measured with body count. Period. Purely a war of attrition. Senseless.

I spent most of my tour attached to Civil Affairs with different units...1st Cav, 1st Army, even the VN Navy. My job was to show up when they had to interact with civilians, so I talked to a lot of farmers, fishermen and shop owners. They didn't seem political at all to me. I don't think they cared who won or lost (not the US, of course....but the north or the south). They just wanted it to be over and for us to leave. The lives they lived weren't really affected much by what form of government they had. The simplicity and serenity of farming, fishing and sense of community transcended that bullshit. Just an impression.
 
Am I defending the Confederacy?

Wars are always started as a quest for political and economic power. They only become great moral struggles in retrospect -- after they have been won.

Really? I think our fight against the Nazis was a moral struggle from the very beginning. Unless you think Roosevelt and Hitler were just jostling and squabbling over political and economic power. Like two schoolboys having a schoolyard fight, or something.
 
I just don't see how a president could assume that power unilaterally ( which is why I offered as a caveat nuclear war or an asteroid, and maybe even little green men popping in).

It's pretty obvious to everyone I threw this out because of Sandy, and from what I've heard today, there's a possibilty power could be out for weeks in the largest metropolitan region of the country. And other effects in dozens of states that will no doubt affect voter turnout to some extent which may very well determine the election. Is that reason enough and who decides. It may surprise you but I happen to think it is reason enough? But who decides? And after that who sets the rules?

Virginia is about to get slammed. Can the Governor just say hey we'll vote next month?

It's not an idle question...we may have to answer it in a few days.

Not "we" here of course....

You may be assuming that there's some formal, written, "Constitutional" process around all this. It would certainly be logical to assume that! But...I think the truth is....that there isn't. Now I'm no Constitutional scholar and for all I know, some sort of "preferred" process" may exist in the context of the law. But as a practical matter - even if there is - it would be trumped by a president's powers as to declaring emergencies. Per those powers, a president is empowered to do (pretty much) whatever he likes - with his only impediment being - curiously in this case - the polls.

I say (pretty much), because I imagine the president is expressly forbidden from doing those things that are expressly forbidden by our Constitution. For instance - even per his emergency powers, the president isn't allowed to enslave people, since the Constitution forbids slavery. But - and this may come as a surprise to us - our Constitution does NOT "give" us the right to vote. Our Constitution says we can't prevent people from voting, based on things like race, gender, and age. For instance, the 19th Amendment says we can't prevent women from voting based on the fact of their being women. But...even as it may seem to imply it, it doesn't grant an absolute right for women TO vote on some pre-scheduled election day.
 
There are two categories of vets. The ones who got there early on thought it was an honorable cause. We had just announced that we would be standing down when I got there. Like Kerry said, "Who wants to be the last one to die in a war that we've already given up on?" (Paraphrased) By 1970, we knew better than to think there was some lofty goal. Success was measured with body count. Period. Purely a war of attrition. Senseless.

I spent most of my tour attached to Civil Affairs with different units...1st Cav, 1st Army, even the VN Navy. My job was to show up when they had to interact with civilians, so I talked to a lot of farmers, fishermen and shop owners. They didn't seem political at all to me. I don't think they cared who won or lost (not the US, of course....but the north or the south). They just wanted it to be over and for us to leave. The lives they lived weren't really affected much by what form of government they had. The simplicity and serenity of farming, fishing and sense of community transcended that bullshit. Just an impression.

Yeah. I think that early on, probably most of our soldiers in Vietnam really believed in the domino theory, and that we had to stop the expansion of Communism. America was still a land of crewcuts, and 'Yes, sir' and 'No, sir' in the schools. And then the war dragged on, and on, and on. I remember---this would've been around 1971 or 1972---getting into an argument about the war with a history teacher in my school. She was gung-ho for the war. Said we had to stop the Soviet Union from taking over the world. I scoffed at her, and said the Soviet Union WANTED us to be over there in Vietnam, wasting our manpower, while they sat back and grinned. That kind of stopped her cold in her tracks. I think I actually made her stop and think. Or re-think.
 
Really? I think our fight against the Nazis was a moral struggle from the very beginning. Unless you think Roosevelt and Hitler were just jostling and squabbling over political and economic power. Like two schoolboys having a schoolyard fight, or something.

No. I suspect it was a much more complex situation than that.
 
Really? I think our fight against the Nazis was a moral struggle from the very beginning. Unless you think Roosevelt and Hitler were just jostling and squabbling over political and economic power. Like two schoolboys having a schoolyard fight, or something.

how could it have been a moral struggle on the part of the usa if they refused to get involved until hitler declared war on them? where was the morality beforehand??
 
Weather should not be the reason for postponing the election.

From what I hear, it's never happened, but I haven't heard anything official.
 
NY Rudy G. postponed the changing of power to Blomberg. I believe elections have been postponed on a local level maybe, but not at National level.

I'm not sure that short of war I would agree with it. But I would think it would have to be a bill passed by congress and signed by the president. Also if I remember right, only states are in charge of elections, and have control over them. Time lines of reporting results are laid out by the federal govt and if states want to participate they will have to follow Federal rules.

But maybe someone who has more knowledge than I do knows for sure
 
Back
Top