New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

I appreciate your efforts Arkady. Cicero is one of the more thoughtful righties. And even he is stuck on "Obama's incompetent" and that somehow Romney is going to ignite a stronger recovery because of his "experience." I don't buy it.

It's not black and white. He can be a flawed president who made dumb mistakes due in part to his minimal national experience, and yet still the best man for the job. I have a long list of criticisms about Obama. I don't need to worship someone to vote for him. But what I'm trying to figure out in this thread is whether Republicans have any decent ideas for things Obama could have done to get the economy growing more robustly.
 
Arkady said:
That's a fundamental misunderstanding. My business needs more production when it perceives demand outstripping the capacity to meet demand. A company isn't going to build a new factory just because profits are up. It's going to build it if the current factory can't make enough widgets to meet the orders they expect to be getting in the coming years.

In fact, corporate profit growth has been very good enough recent years. Extraordinary, in fact, which is why stock market performance under Obama exceeds stock market performance under any other modern president. But a company has a choice of what to do with those profits. It can use them to pay down debt, or to accumulate cash, or it can dividend them out to shareholders, or increase bonuses for senior execs.... or it can hire new people and invest in new infrastructure. Those last two options only make sense if current manpower and infrastructure are seen as being inadequate to meet demand in the near future.

Supply-side policy, as Bruce Bartlett would no doubt attest, has a narrow range of use. An economy either has to have underserved demand at the consumer level and unused capacity at the supply level, or an entirely new industry that warrants incentives to investment. At this point, supply-side policy would actually be worse than useless.
 
I appreciate your efforts Arkady. Cicero is one of the more thoughtful righties. And even he is stuck on "Obama's incompetent" and that somehow Romney is going to ignite a stronger recovery because of his "experience." I don't buy it.

Romney just reminds me too much of Bush. Both had experience as undistinguished governors in states with notoriously weak governorships. And before that, both were successful businessmen, who leveraged startup money and connections from their rich and powerful politician fathers to become even richer. And, as far as I've been able to determine, they each favor identical policies, on every single major topic. Considering that Bush is widely considered one of our worst presidents ever, and considered by at least a few historians to be the VERY WORST ever, and considering his presidency ended in universally-acknowledged disaster, why would anyone want Romney to be president?
 
Arkady,

I have really enjoyed reading through this thread. I am surprised at the number of conservatives who responded and I admire your ability to respond to them patiently. I have several brief additional comments.

First, I would be interested in knowing what you think that Obama might have done over the last four years to kick-start a more robust economic recovery. ( do read Paul Krugman on a regular basis and I am guessing that your answers would be similar to some of the ones that he has proposed. My one difficulty with Krugman is that I may be "institinctively" more of a deficit hawk than I think Krugman is. Do you have any opinions on that? (I am very uncomfortable with wild projections for economic-growth from supply-siders like Paul Ryan in which tax cuts lead to great economic growth and greater overall tax revenues.)

Second, apart from the "theoretical" merits of a case, I am wondering what you thought was genuinely politically possible to do. I think that even Krugman would acknowledge that there were some political factors that helped shape the policies that were actually adopted.

Third, I am as much interested in looking forward as in looking backward. So what would you propose going forward over the next two years. Both Obama and Romney have been a little sketchy on specifics (and I suspect that that is, in part, because they both realize that there are political limits to what they can actually get implemented.) But to the extent that you can decipher things, how do you view the respective plans of Obama and Romney to spur economic growth over the next two years. Romney did, this morning, mention a five point plan (including the repeal of Obamacare) to stimulate the economy and promised that he would create 12 million jobs in four years. Personally, I am very skeptical of Romney's plans (and don't believe that his particular business background gives him great insight into helping to create the conditions for robust economic growth and shared prosperity. I actually think that Obama's plans - as I understand them - are OK but I am not sure that he will be able to get them through Congress. In other words, my concerns are probably more political than economic.

Fourth, what do you think about the relation between the deficit, taxes/tax reform, and the size of government and economic growth. I am guessing that most serious Republicans are going to say that if you lower taxes, reduce the size of government (by spending cuts) that you will reduce the deficit over time and promote more robust economic growth. That is the way that I understand their basic theory. What do you think?

Finally, I have started two successful businesses myself. I think that I do have a good grasp of business policy issues in my industry. But - though I am not illiterate - I do not consider myself to have any particular expertise in public policy related to economic growth.

Unlike a lot of Obama supporters, I'll admit that this economic recovery had been weaker than was necessary, even in light of the absolute mess Bush left. I do, of course, let Obama off the hook for 2009, because I think there was almost nothing he could have done to stop the hemorrhaging faster than he did, given the nature of the crisis (it wasn't a standard business-cycle contraction, like most modern recessions, it was a financial meltdown, like the recession that caused the Great Depression, and like some of the economy-obliterating panics of the 1800s). 2009 was a lost cause, even with the best of policies. But, I believe it was possible to have us restored to robust economic growth and normal job creation before now, and so I fault Obama for not having done so. I'll grant he had very limited options after the Republicans took over Congress and dedicated themselves completely to gridlock. But there are things Obama could have done in '09 and '10 that would have had us much farther along the recovery road today.

If people are interested, I'm happy to provide my thoughts, in detail, about what he could have done differently. But that's not the point of this post. Instead, I'm curious what the conservatives, who are his fiercest critics, think he should have done differently.

Should he have pushed through even more tax cuts than he already did? If so, wouldn't that have resulted in even bigger deficits? And, given the fact that the corporations and the rich are already sitting on piles of money they don't care to invest, due to poor demand growth, how would handing them even more cash have helped? Moreover, doesn't the fact that we had some of the lowest taxes in our modern history, for the eight sub-par economic years leading up to the economic catastrophe, give you pause about the economic efficacy of that method?

The other frequent go-to policy for Republicans is deregulation, but that one's also hard to understand in the current context. We just suffered an economic collapse triggered by the "shadow banking system" -- a system of unregulated and under-regulated financial relationships, using exotic instruments that multiplied and spread economic risk throughout the global system. At best, pushing through more deregulation is like telling an alcoholic to take another drink to calm his hangover.

So, what else should Obama have done, from the conservative perspective?
 
Not that I've ever heard a Republican make that claim, at least there is a direct action to which it can be attached -- Clinton's failure to conduct a real operation that could have taken down Osama bin Laden.

LeRoy: Following your reasoning, and referring back to the post to which you are replying, you should be able to provide some DIRECT ACTION which Obama took during the first few months of his Presidency to explain all of the job losses which were occurring in those months.

What DIRECT ACTION would that be? Taking the oath of office, perhaps?
 
I couldn't agree more. I think that Romney would just be another Bush (though perhaps even less effective.) Now, I think that I give Obama somewhat higher marks than you do given the challenges that he faced but I think that we would both agree that in choosing between Obama and Bush, we would immediately choose Obama. I suspect that Cicero if given the choice between Bush and Obama would choose Bush. But only Cicero knows for sure.

But Cicero has yet to explain to me why anyone should expect more from Romney than they got from Bush.

Romney just reminds me too much of Bush. Both had experience as undistinguished governors in states with notoriously weak governorships. And before that, both were successful businessmen, who leveraged startup money and connections from their rich and powerful politician fathers to become even richer. And, as far as I've been able to determine, they each favor identical policies, on every single major topic. Considering that Bush is widely considered one of our worst presidents ever, and considered by at least a few historians to be the VERY WORST ever, and considering his presidency ended in universally-acknowledged disaster, why would anyone want Romney to be president?
 
Yeah, except for all the memos and warnings of Bin Laden's plans to attack America that were left for the Bushies to read. Especially the one about "airplanes flying into buildings..."

911 happened on Bush' watch. He owns it.

Not that I've ever heard a Republican make that claim, at least there is a direct action to which it can be attached -- Clinton's failure to conduct a real operation that could have taken down Osama bin Laden.
 
Don't forget AJA that Republican Congress shot down....

And the infrastructure initiatives that the GOTP Congress shot down...
 
Mr. Arkady,

Damn, I forgot that legislation only takes one day to pass through congress! ;<) Sorry, my sycophantic friend, Obama started working on the Health care reform pretty much as soon as he took office. I don't know why you presented the red herring about Health Care in Massachusetts, or the fact that it isn't socialist inspired proves it had conservative input, but facts are facts, my friend. Obama never asked for any input from the Repbulicans in Congress, nor did he accept any.

With regards to the stimulus, it was more a continuation of the previous administration's work rather than something he had to do with. Besides, it was just a drop in the bucket which he did little build on. He pretty much dropped the ball to concentrate on his pet project.
 
It's obvious that Republicans haven't had a new idea for decades. Their highest tribute recently is the Obstructionist Party of No. Yet they complain?

Reminds me of that joke: A black waiter keeps bringing platter after platter of delectible food and expensive meats to a large party of GOTP. Each time, the GOTP sends the food back and asks for another platter. Finally, after the tenth platter was refused by the GOTP, one of the GOTP stands up and tells the waiter "It doesn't matter how good the food is, it's YOU we don't like!"

Obama 2012
 
Romney just reminds me too much of Bush. Both had experience as undistinguished governors in states with notoriously weak governorships. And before that, both were successful businessmen, who leveraged startup money and connections from their rich and powerful politician fathers to become even richer. And, as far as I've been able to determine, they each favor identical policies, on every single major topic. Considering that Bush is widely considered one of our worst presidents ever, and considered by at least a few historians to be the VERY WORST ever, and considering his presidency ended in universally-acknowledged disaster, why would anyone want Romney to be president?

This alone should be a top post, Arkady. America's thoughts exactly. Thank you for putting it so succinctly.

Obama 2012
 
Little things like this for starters: http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/domino-effect-obamas-regulations_588106.html

The cause of the 1929 meltdown is far different than the cause of the most recent meltdown. You can't say that just because a patient is sick, you need to have their kidney removed just because, the last time they got sick, removing their kidney worked. The problem in the economy was not systemic in 2008, it was a result of a bubble bursting. Just like with the tech bubble in 2000, government pulled back and the economy got back on track in short order.
 
One big thing Ya-te-hey, no one can negotiate with the Party of No. The Republican Congress would even let Obama's budgets onto the floor. Then there was the AJA- GOTP would pass it. Then there's the fast trains and infrastructure plans that the Party of No torpedoed...1400 bills were knocked down by the House of Reps- including some bills sponsored by the GOTP!!!
 
Back
Top