resident_evil
Senator
Incorrect. Here's a simple test for your theory. You're driving down the street when someone runs a red light and runs into your car, totaling it. You find out the other driver is a foreign national. Does this mean you have no ability to collect damages against him, even though the accident was clearly his fault? Could he simply make a 12(b)(2) civil procedure motion, claiming that any US court lacks personal jurisdiction against him?
https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_12
Of course not. It's well-established that when foreigners come into our borders, they submit to the jurisdiction of US law (federal law and the law of the state they're in). There are partial exceptions for diplomats and a few others:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomatic_immunity
However, assuming he wasn't a diplomat, he's subject to the jurisdiction of the US, notwithstanding being a foreign national. A court can enforce both civil and criminal judgments against him.
The jurisdiction you are referencing is not the one mentioned in the constitution.
If two illegal aliens parents crossed the border to have a child in a border hospital and then turned around to leave back to Mexico with said newborn citizen of the U.S. the government would not be able to kick the parents out and keep the child while using the excuse of the better interest of the child.