New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

No, it isn't. They could not be compelled to serve in the military, serve on juries, etc. FULL jurisdiction - not merely "subject to US authority."
It is full jurisdiction. The US could, if it wanted, impose jury service or military service on foreigners who live here. That it chooses to is simply a question of what the US chooses to do with its jurisdiction, not whether those people are subject to US authority.
 
No, it's not what YOU thought. They were referring to people having "allegiance" to a foreign power, which would include ALL those not yet naturalized or born of naturalized citizens. FULL jurisdiction includes the requirement to serve in the military, serve on juries, etc. It really is quite clear and your effort to legally water it down despite clear evidence to the contrary is an example of why attorneys are held in such low esteem.
The evidence supports my position. I know that troubles you, emotionally, but I'm not going to pretend the words are other than what they are just to spare you the distress of realizing you were wrong.
 
Nope!

Fortunately, we have the highest possible authority on record to answer this question of how the term "jurisdiction" was to be interpreted and applied, the author of the citizenship clause, Sen. Jacob M. Howard (MI) to tell us exactly what it means and its intended scope as he introduced it to the United States Senate in 1866:

Mr. HOWARD: I now move to take up House joint resolution No. 127.

The motion was agreed to; and the Senate, as in Committee of the Whole, resumed the consideration of the joint resolution (H.R. No. 127) proposing an amendment to the Constitution of the United States.

The first amendment is to section one, declaring that all "persons born in the United States and Subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the States wherein they reside. I do not propose to say anything on that subject except that the question of citizenship has been fully discussed in this body as not to need any further elucidation, in my opinion. This amendment which I have offered is simply declaratory of what I regard as the law of the land already, that every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country.[1]


http://www.14thamendment.us/articles/anchor_babies_unconstitutionality.html
You are taking one Senator's idea of what that amendment means. I wonder today if you looked at one Senator's idea of what every law meant if it would jibe with all of the other Senator's idea of what that same laws meant. I don't agree with what this SCOTUS decided on what the 2nd Amendment means when it comes to individuals having the right to own guns, but SCOTUS decides what laws and parts of the constitution mean, not us as individuals.
 
It is full jurisdiction. The US could, if it wanted, impose jury service or military service on foreigners who live here. That it chooses to is simply a question of what the US chooses to do with its jurisdiction, not whether those people are subject to US authority.

Maybe it could but I doubt it. That would be one for the USSC. Regardless, the US has not ever done so. It clearly differentiates resident aliens from citizens with respect to "full jurisdiction." You have any luck finding me all the records of Indians born in the US after 1868 and before 1924 that were declared citizens at birth? I didn't think so. And, for the record, they aren't "foreign dignitaries and ambassadors" (which were listed as examples, not exclusive categories of non-citizen residents).
 
You are taking one Senator's idea of what that amendment means. I wonder today if you looked at one Senator's idea of what every law meant if it would jibe with all of the other Senator's idea of what that same laws meant. I don't agree with what this SCOTUS decided on what the 2nd Amendment means when it comes to individuals having the right to own guns, but SCOTUS decides what laws and parts of the constitution mean, not us as individuals.

He's not just "one senator" - he is the author of the amendment!
 
The evidence supports my position. I know that troubles you, emotionally, but I'm not going to pretend the words are other than what they are just to spare you the distress of realizing you were wrong.

Actually, no, it doesn't. The evidence (including the comments of the drafters of the amendment) support MY position. As does the lack of evidence that any Indian born on US soil after this amendment was treated as a US citizen (until the bill in 1924 stipulated that they were).
 
Maybe it could but I doubt it. That would be one for the USSC. Regardless, the US has not ever done so. It clearly differentiates resident aliens from citizens with respect to "full jurisdiction." You have any luck finding me all the records of Indians born in the US after 1868 and before 1924 that were declared citizens at birth? I didn't think so. And, for the record, they aren't "foreign dignitaries and ambassadors" (which were listed as examples, not exclusive categories of non-citizen residents).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription_in_the_United_States#Non-citizens

The Selective Service (and the draft) in the United States is not limited to citizens. Howard Stringer, for example, was drafted six weeks after arriving from his native Britain in 1965.[102][103] Today, non-citizen males of appropriate age in the United States, who are permanent residents (holders of green cards), seasonal agricultural workers not holding an H-2A Visa, refugees, parolees, asylees, and illegal immigrants, are required to register with the Selective Service System.[104]​

I'm not aware of non-citizens being made to serve on juries, but the idea almost happened in California, before being vetoed by the governor, and I suspect if it hadn't been it would have survived Constitutional challenge:

http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-...own-vetoes-bill-giving-non-citizens-jury-duty

But, even if foreigners are never given jury duty, that doesn't change the calculus about whether their kids born here should be given citizenship. For example, for a long time, women couldn't serve on juries. Yet, if an American woman had a child (even by a foreign father), here in the US, her child was always regarded as a citizen, notwithstanding the fact that, by your reasoning, neither parent was fully subject to US law (since the father was a foreigner and the mother couldn't be drafted or called for jury duty).
 
Actually, no, it doesn't. The evidence (including the comments of the drafters of the amendment) support MY position.

No. You're misreading. Try harder. As for Native Americans, they were treated as having a special status -- a nation within a nation. That's not the case with foreigners.
 
No. You're misreading. Try harder. As for Native Americans, they were treated as having a special status -- a nation within a nation. That's not the case with foreigners.

As were those who were visiting emissaries, or visitors who did not intend to remain and become naturalized citizens. Who in their right mind thinks any foreigner who visits another country while pregnant and has the baby. the baby is automatically a citizen even though the parents are not and must leave when their visa is up (or in the case of illegals they are found and deported). It is an illogical reasoning that was never intended by the 14th Amendment, as was made clear by the adopters at the time.
 
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription_in_the_United_States#Non-citizens

The Selective Service (and the draft) in the United States is not limited to citizens. Howard Stringer, for example, was drafted six weeks after arriving from his native Britain in 1965.[102][103] Today, non-citizen males of appropriate age in the United States, who are permanent residents (holders of green cards), seasonal agricultural workers not holding an H-2A Visa, refugees, parolees, asylees, and illegal immigrants, are required to register with the Selective Service System.[104]​

I'm not aware of non-citizens being made to serve on juries, but the idea almost happened in California, before being vetoed by the governor, and I suspect if it hadn't been it would have survived Constitutional challenge:

http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-...own-vetoes-bill-giving-non-citizens-jury-duty

But, even if foreigners are never given jury duty, that doesn't change the calculus about whether their kids born here should be given citizenship. For example, for a long time, women couldn't serve on juries. Yet, if an American woman had a child (even by a foreign father), here in the US, her child was always regarded as a citizen, notwithstanding the fact that, by your reasoning, neither parent was fully subject to US law (since the father was a foreigner and the mother couldn't be drafted or called for jury duty).

It is illogical to grant automatic citizenship to the baby of non-citizens and then send the baby home to the parents' nation of origin when their visa runs out or they are discovered as being here illegally and deported. Is the baby not also a citizen of the parents' nation of residence? Is it dual citizenship? Both? Neither? That is an absurd interpretation.

And that's not what the framers of the 14th Amendment had in mind and anyone with an ounce of logic understands that immediately. That's why there's only two developed nations with such an illogical interpretation in practice today.
 
As were those who were visiting emissaries, or visitors who did not intend to remain and become naturalized citizens. Who in their right mind thinks any foreigner who visits another country while pregnant and has the baby. the baby is automatically a citizen even though the parents are not and must leave when their visa is up (or in the case of illegals they are found and deported).

Me. I think that's what the fourteenth amendment says, and I think it's a fundamental idea, that our rights are the same regardless of who our parents happen to be.
 
Me. I think that's what the fourteenth amendment says, and I think it's a fundamental idea, that our rights are the same regardless of who our parents happen to be.

If it's such a "fundamental idea" give me a list of all the other countries that follow this idiocy with respect to the children of visiting foreign citizens.
 
It is illogical to grant automatic citizenship to the baby of non-citizens and then send the baby home to the parents' nation of origin when their visa runs out or they are discovered as being here illegally and deported. Is the baby not also a citizen of the parents' nation of residence?

That would depend on the nation.

And that's not what the framers of the 14th Amendment had in mind

Yet the quotation you unearthed suggests that's exactly what the author had in mind, other than in cases of diplomats

Now, I'll grant that our approach is unusual. As with the First Amendment, I think this is one of those areas where the US has the better approach than most other leading nations. If you wish we were more like Europe, for example, I can commiserate, since there are many topics on which I also feel like we should be moving towards the norms of other leading nations. But when it comes to depriving someone born here of the rights of citizenship just because he had the wrong parents, that's something I can't get on board with.
 
Whose time has passed because it is fundamentally unstable and being gamed by illegals and visa scammers.
It doesn't seem to be unstable -- I mean, it's not like the problems of illegal immigration are growing out of control, or our population is surging at a dangerous rate, or anything like that. Illegal immigration is down and our population growth is about as low as it has been in our history -- low enough, in fact, that some of our long-term problems are based around having too few young citizens to support the large generation of older citizens who are retiring. So, I don't see any pressing need to change the rule right now. You apparently do, so what do you see that convinces you that this is no longer a workable idea?
 
It doesn't seem to be unstable -- I mean, it's not like the problems of illegal immigration are growing out of control, or our population is surging at a dangerous rate, or anything like that. Illegal immigration is down and our population growth is about as low as it has been in our history -- low enough, in fact, that some of our long-term problems are based around having too few young citizens to support the large generation of older citizens who are retiring. So, I don't see any pressing need to change the rule right now. You apparently do, so what do you see that convinces you that this is no longer a workable idea?

It is unstable. Illegal immigration is a burden and a costly one at that. All the benefits you ascribe to a high human body count are for a past economic paradigm that is now no longer valid. If you want more people you should consider making abortion less accessible. We are missing well over 50M Americans because of it.
 
I think it's a fundamentally AMERICAN idea.

Haha! Every other fricking idea you come down on the side of the Euro-socialists - EXCEPT this one. Which is why I consider your every argument intellectually bankrupt.
 
It is unstable.

Yes. I understand that's your assertion, but I'm asking what makes you think so. I mean, obviously the country has remained stable for very many generations with this rule and, as I pointed out, we're not currently experiencing any kind of apparent ramp-up in the problems associated with illegal immigration. Quite the contrary, illegal immigration is down, and many of the problems traditionally associated with illegal immigration have been declining, too. So, what cause do we have to think that this phenomenon is now unstable?
 
Back
Top