New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Support for redistribution?

What the hell does pitching in to help your country, that is in desperate shape, have to do with kids giving up points to graduate college? You guys come up with the most ridiculous hypotheticals to justify the wealthiest Americans not helping out more than they already do at a time when their help has never been needed more.

I guess you don't like the answer you got from me about taxes as much as the one you got from college kids about their grade point averages, huh? College kids who will only be able to pay taxes if they have the GPA to graduate and get a job in the field they studied.

Lord, it gets stupid sometimes. Enjoy your hypnosis. The fascists you grovel for in your stupor do.

I'll give you the prize for the most transparent and shameful ploy of the day.

Clap! (Nope. Still nuttin'.)
 
And I call BS...I earned every penny I made, every promotion that I got, every degree that I earned.



Now, tell me which organization I support "that implement racist policies"...I'm conservative and since you've decided all conservatives think and act the same...tell me the name of the organization.

Yet you feel it is your right to claim others do not earn what they have? What makes you different from anyone else claiming they earn and deserve everything they have and more? Seems your statement is moot and meaningless since anyone can claim the same. Actually assessing and proving the claim is true is much more complex and harder.

You see, some people making huge amounts of money feel those making a lot less don't deserve what they make or their desire to make more for what they do, yet those people making huge amounts of money feel they have earned every penny of what they have and that they deserve to make even more. By what rule of thumb and assessment makes their daily activities any more sacred, well earned and deserved than anyone else's?
 
Absolutely the same principle. The only redistribution I'm for is redistributing all of the O'bungle admin back to where they came from come this Nov.
 
Of course it's VASTLY different. Try to picture a GPA system set up along the lines of our monetary system. First, there would be no bell curve. If incomes were grades, nearly all of us would be getting "F"s in the current system. Say you divide income shares into fifths (A, B, C, D, and F, to correspond with standard grading). Then only the top 1% would be getting A's. Someone at the 90th percentile of his class would get a "C." You'd have a few "Ds" after that, but the majority of students would get an "F." And it wouldn't be based on performance. You would be free to inherit your parent's grade. And if you happened to have a high grade in one year, it would make it easier and easier to get high grades in subsequent years, since you'd earn interest on prior test results. On the flip side, if you got a bad start, it would be harder and harder in each subsequent year to get a good grade, since you'd have to pay interest to the students that performed better early on (or inherited good grades from parents).

It's impossible to imagine a grade system that accurately reflects our economic system, which is why using it as an analogy for income redistribution is silly.
 
nothing makes anyone's claims to what's theirs any less valid than another's.... I thought the issue at hand was one making claims against anothers earned pennies...
 
Not even close to the same thing. It's impossible to really imagine a grade system that's akin to our economic system, but even trying can show you the extreme differences. For example, picture a grading system where those with high grades are the ones who write the next rounds of tests. That's akin to our economic system, where the wealthy are the ones who make the laws. And picture a grading system where your starting grade is whatever you inherited from your parents. That's equivalent to our economic system, where income is inheritable. To make a grading system equivalent to our economic system, you'd also need to put an enormous amount of dumb luck into play. For example, picture if there was a lottery where the lucky number got straight A's for life, without ever needing to study again. That's equivalent to our economic system, where there are literal lotteries where dumb luck will get you an upper-class income for life, without another day of work.

The reason people react so negatively to the idea of redistributing grades is because of a sense that grades were distributed more or less in proportion to the work people put in. There simply isn't that same sense when it comes to money in our system. You have the Mitt Romneys and George W. Bushes, who got born to wealth and power, and then you have the masses, who had to make their own way. And the economic system is also vastly more unequal. If I put in a top 5% performance in school, I can expect an A -- the same grade as someone with a top 0.1% performance. In our economic system, by comparison, such tiny fractional differences in performance (or luck) make MASSIVE differences in outcomes. Someone at the 0.1% level will have many times the reward of someone at the 5% level.

The casino nature of our economic system is why people are more open to redistributing a portion of the "winnings" of the lucky few.
 
I seriously doubt it...the same experiment was offered in one of my philosophy classes...everyone who got an A on the exam was asked it they would give up the number of points above 90% to the rest of the class...they would get to keep their A, but it would also mean that others would earn the same grade after the point distribution. The results were the same as in the video...my professor preformed the experiment in several different classes and found none willing to do that. He's actually including these results in a book he is writing.


Then again people are not rational

Would you rather earn $50,000 a year while other people make $25,000, or would you rather earn $100,000 a year while other people get $250,000? Assume for the moment that prices of goods and services will stay the same.

Surprisingly — stunningly, in fact — research shows that the majority of people select the first option; they would rather make twice as much as others even if that meant earning half as much as they could otherwise have. How irrational is that?
 
I TAUGHT at two different universities that used plus and minus on their letter grades....Colorado State University and the University of Northern Colorado. That was years ago. Don't know for sure that they still do, but I would be surprised if they don't.
 
Arkady, you are far more eloquent than I, my friend. I wish I had written that. It was the PERFECT rebuttal to this ridiculous claim about redistributing grade point averages.
 
I think it is fair to say that Number_58 has a surpassingly peculiar definition of luck. And one that a vanishingly small number of Americans would share. Yes, most people figger that Paris Hilton is just plain LUCKY. Never has to work a day in her life. THAT'S luck.
 
Number_68: He's actually including these results in a book he is writing.

LeRoy: Oh, I'm sure that will be a best-selling book! Sheesh. Sounds like an AWFULLY stupid book to me. The editors should take Arkady's post in this thread, the one numbered 67, and put it inside the front cover of this book, as a WARNING to everyone who is intending to read your philosophy professor's magnum opus, on just how silly it is. After they've read the book, they could go back, read Arkady's introduction again, and they could then say to themselves, "Boy! What a stupid book that was!!"
 
Not even close to the same thing. It's impossible to really imagine a grade system that's akin to our economic system, but even trying can show you the extreme differences.

Never been on a college recruiting mission have ya...I'm going to give the most to those who worked the hardest and those who dont work the hardest dont get the most . The reason people react so negatively to the idea of redistributing wealth is because of a sense that wealth were distributed more or less in proportion to the work people put in.

If I put in a top 5% performance in work, I can expect an A -- the same grade as someone with a top 0.1% performance. In our school system, by comparison, such tiny fractional differences in performance (or luck) make MASSIVE differences in outcomes. Someone at the 0.1% level will have many times the reward of someone at the 5% level.

Actually it harder to make it at the top of the class at university than it is to make wealth in America...Those who know the secret of wealth understand that it is based on simple principles that anyone can practice regardless of education, because it is allowed in the free system we have here which employs the use of capitalism. Heck I have even shown lefty how they can use that system to pay for every social program with costing the govt one penny of debt, using principles of wealth , but there it is not likely that I will be valedictorian if I went back to school, wasnt then probably wouldnt now...but I am not broke and wont ever be with out income ever again unless the Democrats come to tax my money to death.
 
I agree that Paris Hilton is lucky to not have to work a day in her life...what I don't consider lucky is that she was born into the Hilton family through some silly genetic lottery belief...there's a HUGE difference.

For you to say she was lucky to be born into the Hilton family due to some genetic lottery belief...you would have to believe that it was possible that she could have been born into some other family besides the Hilton family.
 
Uh, I hope you understand this: The REASON Paris Hilton never has to work a day in her life is BECAUSE she was born into the Hilton family. That is WHY she is LUCKY.

I think most ordinary people would understand the connections between those propositions.
 
I don't do college recruiting missions, but I've written hundreds of recommendations for high school students to get INTO college.

Some kids don't have to study very hard at all to get those grades of A. They're maybe just naturally brilliant. And it certainly helps, in many cases, to come from an affluent family that provides superlative educational opportunities at home early in life. When I write a recommendation for such a student, I may well say that they are 'naturally brilliant, and find their studies to be rather easy'. I think the college admissions officers who decide who to accept to their colleges understand exactly what I am saying there.

And there are students who have to work REALLY HARD to get those high grades. They may not be 'naturally brilliant', but they have an exemplary work ethic. Quite often, they may come from underprivileged backgrounds, and they know, and their parents know, that they are going to have to scratch and claw for everything they get in life. And when I write a recommendation for a student like that, I may well say that they have 'an extraordinary work ethic, and is the type of student that just won't quit." And I think the college admissions officers understand exactly what I am saying there, as well.

Which student do you think is really going to be more successful in the long haul?
 
Yet you feel it is your right to claim others do not earn what they have? What makes you different from anyone else claiming they earn and deserve everything they have and more?

Never claimed others don't earn what they have I think they have...for many, not all, that includes their lot in life. I believe that everyone is deserves everything they achieve and should be able to enjoy such...be it positive or negative. See, you guys seem to forget about the negative part of that.

...some people making huge amounts of money feel those making a lot less don't deserve what they make or their desire to make more for what they do

I'm not one of those people so...how is it you put it...oh yeah, "your statement is moot and meaningless" where I'm concerned here.

Don't attempt to translate to me my feelings or thoughts...truth is, you have no idea.
 
One's GPA and income are not the same. One earns one's own GPA, but income is a slice of profit which bares no or little resemblence to individual effort. If one got what earned from work, capitalists, on the whole, would make very little income and workers would take home most profit.

Well, not when it effects them directly. Most of these 4.0 GPA students support raising taxes on the top 10%, but view it as different when asked to give some of their GPA points to the students with lower GPAs. Which leads to the question...is it different and if so, why?

[video=youtube;lOyaJ2UI7Ss]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOyaJ2UI7Ss[/video]
 
Nope...luck had nothing to do with her being born into the Hilton family...it's just a FACT that she was born into that family. I don't know how many different ways I have to put this...if it had anything to do with luck, that means the possibility that she could have been born into a family with the last name of Smith was just as possible...sorry, but that just doesn't compute.
 
Back
Top