New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Violent Cities

I think that's one thing that made a difference in the Clinton years. Violent crime rates had reached their all-time peak near the end of the failed Reagan/Bush era, but then fell incredibly rapidly once Clinton took office. Although the improvement has continued since Clinton left office, it's been at a greatly diminished rate (especially in the Bush years). I think the part of the reason is that Clinton helped push through a measure that put a lot more cops on the street. There's this idea people have that deterrence is best accomplished with draconian penalties, but people's minds don't really work like that. They factor in the probability of being caught vastly more than the consequences if they are caught. Put a lot more cops on the street and you are going to have a bigger deterrent effect than locking up ever greater numbers. I think that was the real key to the 1994 crime bill. It's been bashed by some liberals based on the way incarceration rates rose after 1994. But the truth is they rose at a lower rate than before 1994. The extra incarceration wasn't the magic. The magic was 100,000 more community police officers.
Clinton's claim to have put 100,000 new cops on the street and sent the crime rate "way down" was given a Three Pinocchio rating by Kessler in the Washington Post.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...hat-100000-cops-sent-the-crime-rate-way-down/

The GAO basically destroyed Clinton's (and your) phony claims. The number of officers on the street never got close to 100,000. It may actually have peaked at 62,000.
Also the GAO reported nationwide, crime rates
began to decline in about 1991, before the COPS program announced its
first grant programs in 1994. Hence the factors other than COPS
grants that were responsible for precipitating the decline in crime could
have continued to influence its decline throughout the 1990s. Researchers
have pointed to a number of factors that could have precipitated the
decline in crime, including increased use of prison as a punishment for
violent crimes, improved economic conditions, and the subsiding of
violence that accompanied the expansion of drug markets. To the extent
that any of these factors are correlated with the distribution of COPS
grants, they could be responsible for impacts that have been attributed to
COPS grants.

http://www.gao.gov/assets/250/248152.pdf
 
You brought up violent cities.

Yes. And you brought up guns.

You saying guns play no role in that?

If you read, you'll see I wasn't saying anything about guns one way or the other.

"Surrounding areas?" Then why are you even talking about "Violent Cities?"

The issue of comparing cities had come up in other threads, and so I thought there'd be benefit in calling the forum's attention to a difficulty when comparing cities on the basis of whatever their municipal borders happen to be, since that will often mean an apples-to-oranges comparison of big cities on one hand and small cities plus their suburban and even rural areas on the other.

This issue isn't just a concern that applies to gun control. No matter how you propose to address America's violence problem, understanding the geography of violence will run into that issue of how to do meaningful comparisons among cities. For that matter, it could be an issue not just with analyzing violence but with analyzing almost any sociological issue.

For example, say you want to analyze urban transportation issues and you put together a ranking of what percentage of workers in each city commute on foot. You may find a fairly high percentage in Boston and a low percentage in Oklahoma City, but that may have less to do with actual transit policy or even culture in each place than just being a side-effect of how each draws their borders. Official Boston is just the urban core -- about four miles average radius. So, of course, a fairly large number of people who live and work there will be able to commute on foot. Official Oklahoma City is a pretty small urban core plus a lot of far-flung suburbs and ex-urbs, well beyond the range of a pedestrian commute. If OK City drew its municipal borders tightly around the urban core like Boston does, the statistical comparison might look very different.

Another way to think of the issue is to imagine what a city could do to address some measured problem. For example, what could Boston do to lower its murder rate? There are lots of substantive options, but how about this simple one: merge with its closest suburbs. It could add Cambridge, Brookline, Newton, Weston, Waltham, Wellesley, Milton, Dedham, Watertown, and Quincy, for example. In terms of land area it would still be a fairly small city -- less than a third the size of Oklahoma City or Houston, for example. In terms of population, it would be in the range of Dallas. In terms of crime stats, it would suddenly look much better than before, thanks to averaging in all those suburbs, many of which have extremely low crime rates.

Yet, such a change wouldn't actually make anybody safer. Everyone would still have the same crime risk as before -- it would just be consolidated into a more diverse geographic footprint, similar to what we see in many other cities (OK City, Houston, Dallas, etc.), factoring in the inner 'burbs. That makes it clear why it's so problematic to rely on those official municipal borders for analyzing policy issues. That's why I posted -- to caution people that if we're to analyze urban policy questions meaningfully, we need to make sure we're doing meaningful comparisons, and MSA data allows for that.
 
Clinton's claim to have put 100,000 new cops on the street and sent the crime rate "way down" was given a Three Pinocchio rating by Kessler in the Washington Post.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...hat-100000-cops-sent-the-crime-rate-way-down/

The GAO basically destroyed Clinton's (and your) phony claims. The number of officers on the street never got close to 100,000. It may actually have peaked at 62,000.
Also the GAO reported nationwide, crime rates
began to decline in about 1991, before the COPS program announced its
first grant programs in 1994. Hence the factors other than COPS
grants that were responsible for precipitating the decline in crime could
have continued to influence its decline throughout the 1990s. Researchers
have pointed to a number of factors that could have precipitated the
decline in crime, including increased use of prison as a punishment for
violent crimes, improved economic conditions, and the subsiding of
violence that accompanied the expansion of drug markets. To the extent
that any of these factors are correlated with the distribution of COPS
grants, they could be responsible for impacts that have been attributed to
COPS grants.

http://www.gao.gov/assets/250/248152.pdf
Whether it was 100,000 or 62,000 isn't particularly relevant to this analysis. The issue is whether it was a substantial increase or not. If so, it's a plausible candidate for what accelerated the crime decline. If not, it's not. Was 62,000 a big increase in relative terms or not?

As for the fact the decline started before the grant programs went into force, that's true. However, note that I've already mentioned that a slower pace of improvement continued after Clinton. That doesn't undermine the argument, and so neither would the fact that a slow pace of improvement preceded the program. The claim here isn't that the cops program was responsible for the entirety of the improvement, but rather that it may be part of what transformed a background rate of slow improvement into very rapid improvement for a time.

Specifically, the violent crime rate hit its all time peak in 1991. In 1992, there was a tiny bit of improvement (just 0.079%). 1993, Clinton's first year, saw stronger improvement, with 1.413%, but that was still nothing terribly dramatic. 1994, though, when the first grant programs started, started a series of much more dramatic improvements -- between around 4% and 7.6% each of the six years starting in 1994. After that, we never hit 4% improvement again until Obama took office.

That pattern of data is what we'd expect to see if there was a background phenomenon encouraging declining crime throughout the 1992-present period (e.g., thanks to de-leading of gas in prior generation), but there was something special in 1994 and the first several years after, which built upon that background rate for some truly dramatic year-on-year improvements. Was it the COPs program? Gun control? Something else? Tough to say. But the program is at least a plausible candidate based on timing.
 
Especially given that you're covering for yet another Clinton lie.
I'm not. I have taken no position on whether it was 100,000 or 62,000, much less whether Clinton knew he was making a false claim. I'm not discussing the question of whether he was honest or not. I'm discussing the question of whether the boost in police factored into the incredibly rapid decline in crime.
 
If you read, you'll see I wasn't saying anything about guns one way or the other.

K

The issue of comparing cities had come up in other threads,

Whoops! Now you're talking about guns again. I know the threads you're talking about. I posted in them. And. . .they were about guns!

See, this blah blah is all just one big fat distraction. You come up with a new metric and I hammer you with it by challenging you to employ it in a comparison between Detroit and, oh, hell, I dunno. Any city. I offered Denver and El Paso.

You still haven't made that comparison because it blows your "theory" right out of the water.

Oh but it's STATS! So it's mathy and truthy! And you'll cling to it because you think you're a good bullshitter.
 
Whoops! Now you're talking about guns again. I know the threads you're talking about. I posted in them. And. . .they were about guns!

The reason I posted to the top and made no mention of guns is the point is generally applicable when analyzing any policy when it comes to urban areas, not just applicable when it comes to gun control discussions.

See, this blah blah is all just one big fat distraction.

No. It's a way to help lower-IQ people like you to grasp an issue that you wouldn't have spotted on your own.

You still haven't made that comparison because it blows your "theory" right out of the water.

If you think a comparison between two cities would blow my theory out of the water, you didn't understand the theory at all. It makes no predictions about Detroit one way or the other. It merely says that to compare Detroit meaningfully to other cities we need to use similarly drawn boundaries (e.g. MSA to MSA).
 
If you think a comparison between two cities would blow my theory out of the water, you didn't understand the theory at all. It makes no predictions about Detroit one way or the other. It merely says that to compare Detroit meaningfully to other cities we need to use similarly drawn boundaries (e.g. MSA to MSA).
. . .like Denver and El Paso! Hello? All three have similar populations and boundaries. That's why I chose them!

And you still haven't made that comparison!

And you call me low IQ. Ha! Triple 9 my ass!
 
. . .like Denver and El Paso!

First, Denver and El Paso are quite different in terms of boundaries. Denver has a population density of 4044/sq mi, while El Paso has a density of 2,500/sq mi. You'd have to increase Denver's footprint by over 60% for it to have a similar profile to El Paso, in terms of how the borders are drawn around the city.

But, of course, there will be other examples of cities with roughly similar boundaries. For those, my argument doesn't apply -- they can be compared meaningfully using official boundaries, rather than using MSAs, or otherwise needing to find a way to make it an apples to apples comparison.
 
First, Denver and El Paso are quite different in terms of boundaries. Denver has a population density of 4044/sq mi, while El Paso has a density of 2,500/sq mi. You'd have to increase Denver's footprint by over 60% for it to have a similar profile to El Paso, in terms of how the borders are drawn around the city.

But, of course, there will be other examples of cities with roughly similar boundaries. For those, my argument doesn't apply -- they can be compared meaningfully using official boundaries, rather than using MSAs, or otherwise needing to find a way to make it an apples to apples comparison.

You're dancing your ass off.
 
Let's take the bottom ten, the real shitholes of America:

Houston - mayor Sylvester Turner, Democrat
Atlanta - mayor Kasim Reed, Democrat
Miami - mayor Tomas Regalado, Republican
San Francisco - mayor Ed Lee, Democrat
Chicago - mayor Rahm Emanuel, Democrat
St. Louis - mayor Francis Slay, Democrat
Kansas City - mayor Sly James, Independent (but is a DNC superdelegate)
Philadelphia - mayor Jim Kenney, Democrat
Baltimore - mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, Democrat
Detroit - mayor Mike Duggan, Democrat

Looks about right to me.

How in the F*CK could anyone vote for a politician named Sly James?????? :)
 
No, I don't think it's a coincidence. I've explained what I think is the mechanism for this correlation before.

In some areas (e.g., New England, Scandinavia), the lower class mostly looks like the ruling class. This makes it easier for the ruling class to feel empathy for the lower class. They don't look at poor people and see something like a completely different species, to be feared and loathed. Instead, they think "there but for the grace of God go I." This inspires more liberal approaches to the problems of the lower class.

For example, in more liberal areas there's a focus on integration (e.g., affordable housing programs that rely on promoting mixed-income development), rather than a focus on segregation (e.g., affordable housing programs that rely on large, centralized "projects" for the poor... projects that devolve into slums). When the ruling class sees the lower class as people just like them, albeit with less money, you get fewer gated communities, less flight of the wealthy from urban centers, less of a reliance on economically/racially segregated private schools, less resistance to integrated low-income development, etc. And social programs get focused more on providing a hand up, rather than being built around a suspicion that "those people" are just lazy folks looking for an excuse not to work. There's also more of a focus on early intervention to prevent violence, rather than on just arming the majority population so it can "take out" the bad guys, and throwing as many lawbreakers behind bars for long periods as possible.

Thus, when, thanks to historical factors, the underclass is mostly black (or Hispanic) while the ruling class is mostly non-Hispanic white, the alienation of the underclass from the ruling class tends to produce a bunch of ineffectual or counter-productive policies. In Boston (or Munich, for that matter), that's somewhat less of an issue, since there are so many non-Hispanic whites in the lower class that it allows for a more empathetic (and thus more successful) approach to public policy. When a society's leaders see its lower class as decent people who can thrive with a little help, that is going to work a lot better than when they see the lower class as "animals" who need to be isolated and intimidated to keep them from hurting the decent people.

I totally get the "but for the grace of God go I", though suspect you and I might word it differently. Still, same thought and clearly the way to state the sentiment.

Of course, I see things differently. I've been poor. I've been irresponsible. As such, I associated with many people like me. A large majority of people I associated with had serious character flaws that kept them (and me) where they were (and I was) at. Personally, I made substances a priority. Others I knew did the same. Others were just lazy and didn't like to work.

To me, empathy is something an individual engages in. It is not a government action. This is similar to my view on charity. To me, charity is a spirit of giving that leads a person to want to help others. I won't sit here and toot my horn very much, but I'll give an example. When I hire day laborers, I always pay them a few bucks over the going rate, feed them lunch and offer them food from the pantry. I'm sure many people do that and more. Again, it's not about tooting my own horn. It's about realizing that government taking by force from one group and giving to another isn't charity nor empathy.

Regarding housing, why shouldn't poor people live with other poor people? If such a setup ends up with ghettos, that's the responsibility of the residents. I see no reason why we should infect nice neighborhoods with poor people who are far more likely to engage in crime and bring down the area they are moved to. It certainly doesn't lift people up.
 
I totally get the "but for the grace of God go I", though suspect you and I might word it differently. Still, same thought and clearly the way to state the sentiment.

Of course, I see things differently. I've been poor. I've been irresponsible. As such, I associated with many people like me. A large majority of people I associated with had serious character flaws that kept them (and me) where they were (and I was) at. Personally, I made substances a priority. Others I knew did the same. Others were just lazy and didn't like to work.

To me, empathy is something an individual engages in. It is not a government action. This is similar to my view on charity. To me, charity is a spirit of giving that leads a person to want to help others. I won't sit here and toot my horn very much, but I'll give an example. When I hire day laborers, I always pay them a few bucks over the going rate, feed them lunch and offer them food from the pantry. I'm sure many people do that and more. Again, it's not about tooting my own horn. It's about realizing that government taking by force from one group and giving to another isn't charity nor empathy.

Regarding housing, why shouldn't poor people live with other poor people? If such a setup ends up with ghettos, that's the responsibility of the residents. I see no reason why we should infect nice neighborhoods with poor people who are far more likely to engage in crime and bring down the area they are moved to. It certainly doesn't lift people up.



you dont lift up one by dragging down another...its counter productive...
 
I totally get the "but for the grace of God go I", though suspect you and I might word it differently. Still, same thought and clearly the way to state the sentiment.

Of course, I see things differently. I've been poor. I've been irresponsible. As such, I associated with many people like me. A large majority of people I associated with had serious character flaws that kept them (and me) where they were (and I was) at. Personally, I made substances a priority. Others I knew did the same. Others were just lazy and didn't like to work.

To me, empathy is something an individual engages in. It is not a government action. This is similar to my view on charity. To me, charity is a spirit of giving that leads a person to want to help others. I won't sit here and toot my horn very much, but I'll give an example. When I hire day laborers, I always pay them a few bucks over the going rate, feed them lunch and offer them food from the pantry. I'm sure many people do that and more. Again, it's not about tooting my own horn. It's about realizing that government taking by force from one group and giving to another isn't charity nor empathy.

Regarding housing, why shouldn't poor people live with other poor people? If such a setup ends up with ghettos, that's the responsibility of the residents. I see no reason why we should infect nice neighborhoods with poor people who are far more likely to engage in crime and bring down the area they are moved to. It certainly doesn't lift people up.


That is what the left always wants to ignore. The bad choices and character flaws that land people where they are. Some figure it out, and get out. But, there is nothing about being poor that means you don't take care of where you live. And, yet, ghettos are full of trash and vandalized and intentionally damaged. Why is that? Because of the kind of people that live there. Taking that kind of trash out of the ghetto and put it into nice neighborhoods only makes the nice neighborhoods bad.

If that were not the case then all this whining about "white flight" would never have caused communities to become crapholes. If everyone moving there, were good, with good morals, sense of pride in their community and valued cleanliness, organization, private property, etc. - then the neighborhoods would not have been trashed. But, its clear that allowing low income people in- brings with it the problems that keep the vast majority of them low income.

If instead, you are dedicated to improving your life you can. But, what does that mean? it means you likely don't actually associate with the trash you live around. you are busy, very very busy all the time, working as much as you possibly can and taking any learning opportunities you have. You therefore lack the time to get into trouble. You aren't in the wrong place at the wrong time, because you are never anywhere other than work or in bed. You don't have a child out of wedlock that you can't afford because not only do you not have the time to find someone to Fvck you don't actually have the time or energy to Fvck. If you do - then you are not trying hard enough to better yourself.

But, people - they don't try that hard. The let life happen to them, instead of developing a plan and specific goals and methodically working towards them. Some may not be inherrently bad people, but their inability to productively organize and order their lives, their associations, and thier aspierations means they will never get anywhere.

Very very very few people find themselves in poverty - by some horrible tragedy that occured to them overnight. Instead it is the result of systematically making poor choices. Plain and simple. The reason why they can't fix it - is that the left deny's the problem.

connie
 
First, Denver and El Paso are quite different in terms of boundaries. Denver has a population density of 4044/sq mi, while El Paso has a density of 2,500/sq mi. You'd have to increase Denver's footprint by over 60% for it to have a similar profile to El Paso, in terms of how the borders are drawn around the city.

But, of course, there will be other examples of cities with roughly similar boundaries. For those, my argument doesn't apply -- they can be compared meaningfully using official boundaries, rather than using MSAs, or otherwise needing to find a way to make it an apples to apples comparison.
No. You really are dancing your ass off.

Try making a comparison that doesn't make you look illiterate or retarded. Try comparing Detroit and Denver like the original challenge stated.
 
Interesting post..... I did a quick check. 25% of Boston is black.

https://www.google.com/?gws_rd=ssl#q=percentage of boston that is black people

83% of Detroit is black.

https://www.google.com/?gws_rd=ssl#q=percentage of detroit that is black people

Blacks have a much higher violent crime rate than other races. Is it coincidence there is such a demographic difference in the lowest big city crime rate versus the highest?

I'll let the individual reader decide.

I'm old enough to remember when Detroit wasn't dangerous at all. Urban Detroit was both black and white and the suburbs were all white. Blue-collar city where you could find all the trouble you wanted if you went looking but otherwise peaceful. Until the '67 riot brought by Rap Brown and his stinking black panthers. And why did Rap and his mao mao thugs come to Detroit? Because LBJ was tearing down the black neighborhoods and putting the people in the projects/prisons. Before that rotten old bastard and his stooges stepped in, Detroit was a thriving, clean, well-run city. And of course, there was the OPEC oil embargo which let the japs get a foothold with their shitty little tin can cars.
 
Back
Top