connieb
Senator
You spend a lot of time concocting positions I do not hold and arguing against them - strawmen. I'll ignore that and focus on your response to what I did say.
You stubbornly refuse to admit that poor and middle class people will buy more goods and services if they had more money. You even go so far as to say that bills paid with extra money would otherwise never get paid at all. I'm sure you know that's a daffy proposition - you're grasping at straws.
And you just ignore what I said about the redistributive effect of taxation no matter how it is structured. You spout platitudes instead and yammer about spendings levels, which is irrelevant to the question of adjusting the tax burdens of the wealthy vis-a-vis others. You seem to have nothing to say on the actual point I made.
Poor and middle class people often do not pay their bills which is why thier credit generally sucks. And, you can call it "daffy" all you like but when the last stimulus checks went out- the money did not find its way into cash being spent. It was saved for an emergency or to replenish emergency funds or paid off something that otherwise would not have been paid off.
I did not ignore. I have openly disagreed that all taxation is redistributive. It simply is not. Taxation - how it should be used is not re- distributive at all. How it is used is this country is - and is being used wrongly. So, no there should be no redistributive effect of taxation. That is exactly what I would like to get away from. We should each pay for an equal percentage portion of the services necessary to run the country. There should be no tax which comes back as social welfare, so there should be no redistribute effect of it.
You are not making any point. You are simply spouting talking points.