New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Flat Tax Math

I'll ignore your concoctions of what I supposedly believe. I say what I believe.

And one thing I believe is that it's fantasy to think that everyone can save money. Many people spend every cent they earn and they still live in squalor and go hungry. If consumers did manage to save money, less purchase of goods and services would take place, the economy would take a hit, and more people would lose their jobs. A horrible cycle. The solution is putting more money in the hands of consumers by doing things like shifting tax burden upward, hiking the minimum wage, curtailing outsourcing, and strengthening unions - all bitterly opposed by the GOP.

Yes, that's the Marxist approach and we've been trying that for the past 6 plus years and the economy still sucks:

https://www.frbatlanta.org/cqer/researchcq/gdpnow.cfm

Time to try a little capitalism (like Clinton did) and get the economy growing again.
 
Yes, that's the Marxist approach and we've been trying that for the past 6 plus years and the economy still sucks:

https://www.frbatlanta.org/cqer/researchcq/gdpnow.cfm

Time to try a little capitalism (like Clinton did) and get the economy growing again.

There's not a lick of difference between the economic views of Clinton and Obama. Indeed, when Clinton enacted his economic policies we heard the same yammering we now get from you and your ilk as to Obama. But looking back on the best economic years in US history, you attempt revisionism as to the Clinton economic platform. Adding to the craziness, you simply deny the vast economic improvements under Obama. It's laughble.
 
That's two regressive proposals. The wealth gap would soar.

The only reason the very wealthy have gotten obscenely wealthy lately is because of the federal government's actions -1) borrowing and spending and 2) depreciating the dollar.

I'm against both of those aspects of the federal government. Once we stop the feds from enriching the oligarchs, the economy will do better and more people of modest means will be able to save and invest in a small business and grow richer. Of course, there will always be some people who do not want to or can't participate in the capitalist system and they will always be poor. But a wealthier middle class will produce more tax revenue to support the programs for them than will your oligarch supporting big government utopia.
 
There's not a lick of difference between the economic views of Clinton and Obama. Indeed, when Clinton enacted his economic policies we heard the same yammering we now get from you and your ilk as to Obama. But looking back on the best economic years in US history, you attempt revisionism as to the Clinton economic platform. Adding to the craziness, you simply deny the vast economic improvements under Obama. It's laughble.

"Era of big government is over" vs. "you didn't build that." Nuff said...
 
The only reason the very wealthy have gotten obscenely wealthy lately is because of the federal government's actions -1) borrowing and spending and 2) depreciating the dollar.

I'm against both of those aspects of the federal government. Once we stop the feds from enriching the oligarchs, the economy will do better and more people of modest means will be able to save and invest in a small business and grow richer. Of course, there will always be some people who do not want to or can't participate in the capitalist system and they will always be poor. But a wealthier middle class will produce more tax revenue to support the programs for them than will your oligarch supporting big government utopia.

Ridiculous. Massive tax cuts for the wealthy further enriched them to an enormous degree. The GOP has brainwashed you to the point that you can't even perceive the obvious.
 
I'll ignore your concoctions of what I supposedly believe. I say what I believe.

And one thing I believe is that it's fantasy to think that everyone can save money. Many people spend every cent they earn and they still live in squalor and go hungry. If consumers did manage to save money, less purchase of goods and services would take place, the economy would take a hit, and more people would lose their jobs. A horrible cycle. The solution is putting more money in the hands of consumers by doing things like shifting tax burden upward, hiking the minimum wage, curtailing outsourcing, and strengthening unions - all bitterly opposed by the GOP.

It is not a fantasy to believe everyone can save. There was a fascinating article I read a few years ago about the "poverty mentality" as it came to finances, and the mistakes that the people in poverty make which keeps them from being able to save and get out of poverty. Moreover, in our system - they are penalized if they save by being kicked off of benefits they use and need and which gave them the chance to save by setting ridiculously low savings and assets limits in order to qualify for things. Thus it perpetuates the bad spending habits of the poor.

The "solution" is however not taking more from the rich to give to the poor no matter how you want to slice, dice or rephrase it. The solution comes in many ways including not only the increased availability of middle class jobs, not stupid retail jobs and service jobs. And, educating people on their finances, continuing to encourage everyone to put of child bearing until they have completed their educations and are in stable committed relationships, put off childbearing until you are self supporting and can afford the family you want to create, etc. And, if that means - it never happens, it never happens. There is noting more cruel or selfish than bringing a child in the world when your current living situation is impoverished.


No matter how poor the family of your origin, you are not destined to be poor if you don't want to. If however you follow in their footsteps and have children you do not have the means to support, get into trouble with the law, develop drug or alcohol problems, do not get an education, etc., you will be.
 
Snippets of speeches do not describe economic platforms. You know that, but you dishonestly pretend to the contrary.

Nuff said.

You are the master at "dishonesty" so I find it rather ironic that you would suggest that I am being dishonest. Perhaps you have (Saul Alinsky lover) Hillary Clinton confused with her husband Bill. Bill is a capitalist. Obama and Hillary are both Marxists. That means other than the D behind their names, they do not all subscribe to the same economic philosophy.
 
It is not a fantasy to believe everyone can save. There was a fascinating article I read a few years ago about the "poverty mentality" as it came to finances, and the mistakes that the people in poverty make which keeps them from being able to save and get out of poverty. Moreover, in our system - they are penalized if they save by being kicked off of benefits they use and need and which gave them the chance to save by setting ridiculously low savings and assets limits in order to qualify for things. Thus it perpetuates the bad spending habits of the poor.

The "solution" is however not taking more from the rich to give to the poor no matter how you want to slice, dice or rephrase it. The solution comes in many ways including not only the increased availability of middle class jobs, not stupid retail jobs and service jobs. And, educating people on their finances, continuing to encourage everyone to put of child bearing until they have completed their educations and are in stable committed relationships, put off childbearing until you are self supporting and can afford the family you want to create, etc. And, if that means - it never happens, it never happens. There is noting more cruel or selfish than bringing a child in the world when your current living situation is impoverished.


No matter how poor the family of your origin, you are not destined to be poor if you don't want to. If however you follow in their footsteps and have children you do not have the means to support, get into trouble with the law, develop drug or alcohol problems, do not get an education, etc., you will be.

Generalities does not get us there. Sure, a "solution" is "the increased availability of middle class jobs." But how to get there? That's the challenging part.

Other than that, you touch upon a slew of social issues. All legitimate issues but, if they could be solved at all, it would take decades. On the other hand, shifting more of the tax burden away from the poor and middle class, and on to the wealthy, could be done today. We need only to change tax laws and other pertinent laws that created the wealth gap in the first place. As to such changes, all we get from the GOP is resistance, as the gap grows more and more by the day.
 
You are the master at "dishonesty" so I find it rather ironic that you would suggest that I am being dishonest. Perhaps you have (Saul Alinsky lover) Hillary Clinton confused with her husband Bill. Bill is a capitalist. Obama and Hillary are both Marxists. That means other than the D behind their names, they do not all subscribe to the same economic philosophy.

Nah, you right wingers called Clinton a Marxist too when he jacked up taxes on the wealthy. Given the fantastic economy we had after Clinton jacked up those taxes, you're engaging in pure revisionism in an effort to justify your ideology. It's lame.
 
Generalities does not get us there. Sure, a "solution" is "the increased availability of middle class jobs." But how to get there? That's the challenging part.

Other than that, you touch upon a slew of social issues. All legitimate issues but, if they could be solved at all, it would take decades. On the other hand, shifting more of the tax burden away from the poor and middle class, and on to the wealthy, could be done today. We need only to change tax laws and other pertinent laws that created the wealth gap in the first place. As to such changes, all we get from the GOP is resistance, as the gap grows more and more by the day.

How to get there is to make policies which promote job grownth and the relocation of businesses to get back here. Lower tax rates on businesses is one option - so that it is less expensive to do busienss here than abroad. Offering credits of all income taxes to open facilities or expand facilities would be another.

I don't care how long it will take. It is within the power of each person to do those things for themselves. The Tax BURDEN should go down for everyone by drastically cutting and gutting the Federal Gov't bureaucracy. But the top already pay the lions share of the taxes in this country and to furthre remove the individual from the obligation they helped to create only with further reduce their incentive to make the changes they need to as an individual.
 
How to get there is to make policies which promote job grownth and the relocation of businesses to get back here. Lower tax rates on businesses is one option - so that it is less expensive to do busienss here than abroad. Offering credits of all income taxes to open facilities or expand facilities would be another.

I don't care how long it will take. It is within the power of each person to do those things for themselves. The Tax BURDEN should go down for everyone by drastically cutting and gutting the Federal Gov't bureaucracy. But the top already pay the lions share of the taxes in this country and to furthre remove the individual from the obligation they helped to create only with further reduce their incentive to make the changes they need to as an individual.

One either wants to shrink the wealth gap, or one does not. Your words indicate that you do not. So be it.

As to outsourcing of jobs, changes to our laws made it highly attractive for companies to do that. Those changes could be reversed - stop providing companies with financial incentives to outsource. Just "cutting their taxes" does nothing constructive, and just increases the gap.
 
One either wants to shrink the wealth gap, or one does not. Your words indicate that you do not. So be it.

As to outsourcing of jobs, changes to our laws made it highly attractive for companies to do that. Those changes could be reversed - stop providing companies with financial incentives to outsource. Just "cutting their taxes" does nothing constructive, and just increases the gap.

I do not give a shit about the wealth gap. So, there is my opinion on that. I believe with business and jobs friendly environment it will close on its own. I do not believe in trying to manipulate it by artificially redistrubuting wealth.

Cutting their taxes ( and possibly regulation ) in order to make it more attractive to do business here - will bring them back. I do not advocate taking away options and thus more regulation- I advocate providing incentives.
 
I do not give a shit about the wealth gap. So, there is my opinion on that. I believe with business and jobs friendly environment it will close on its own. I do not believe in trying to manipulate it by artificially redistrubuting wealth.

Cutting their taxes ( and possibly regulation ) in order to make it more attractive to do business here - will bring them back. I do not advocate taking away options and thus more regulation- I advocate providing incentives.

OK, but many people do care about the wealth gap. We see it as the primary cause of tepid economic growth. Reverse it, increase demand for goods and services by the consumer classes, and the economy booms.

But note how you call tax hikes on the wealthy "artificially redistributing wealth." Tax laws always redistribute wealth by their very nature. Did you bash tax cuts for the wealthy as "artificially redistributing wealth"?
 
OK, but many people do care about the wealth gap. We see it as the primary cause of tepid economic growth. Reverse it, increase demand for goods and services by the consumer classes, and the economy booms.

But note how you call tax hikes on the wealthy "artificially redistributing wealth." Tax laws always redistribute wealth by their very nature. Did you bash tax cuts for the wealthy as "artificially redistributing wealth"?

And, you may see it that way, but you would be wrong. Reversing it - most likely will result in what happened a few years ago when the stimulus checks went out - people use them to pay off the bills they have already incurred and don't spend hardly any new money. Your there will be more money so there will be more demand si really a figment of your imagination and does not address quite frankly that even the poor people in this country are swimming in consumer goods already. Getting them to spend a little more at Walmart is not going to spur the economy.

I think any tax hike designed to provide from one to the other is an artificial distribution of wealth. Taxes which are used for a specific purpose - like defense or road building - where each person pays their share, is not distributive. Since BUSH was as bad or worse with economic policy as Obama, and he was also just another Big' Gov't statistic war monger, you can be sure, that I disagree with everything he did.


connie
 
And, you may see it that way, but you would be wrong. Reversing it - most likely will result in what happened a few years ago when the stimulus checks went out - people use them to pay off the bills they have already incurred and don't spend hardly any new money. Your there will be more money so there will be more demand si really a figment of your imagination and does not address quite frankly that even the poor people in this country are swimming in consumer goods already. Getting them to spend a little more at Walmart is not going to spur the economy.

I think any tax hike designed to provide from one to the other is an artificial distribution of wealth. Taxes which are used for a specific purpose - like defense or road building - where each person pays their share, is not distributive. Since BUSH was as bad or worse with economic policy as Obama, and he was also just another Big' Gov't statistic war monger, you can be sure, that I disagree with everything he did.


connie

If you just refuse to believe that poor and middle class people will spend money on goods and services if they get it, so be it. Economists know better.

And again, you say that hiking taxes on the wealthy "is an artificial distribution of wealth," but you refuse to say whether the same is true when taxes on the wealthy are slashed. Why?
 
If you just refuse to believe that poor and middle class people will spend money on goods and services if they get it, so be it. Economists know better.

And again, you say that hiking taxes on the wealthy "is an artificial distribution of wealth," but you refuse to say whether the same is true when taxes on the wealthy are slashed. Why?

They will pay off bills they already incurred.THAT is what we know they will do with it because it is what they did with the stimulus. Morever, I don't think encouraging the poor and middle class to spend more - is the way to help them build wealth. So, if they are infact just going to spend it, then I would rather not give it to them. That is quite the waste of artifically continuing to prop up this economy.

Because - anyone getting to keep more of their own money is not a redistribution. The money was theirs to being with - taking less of it is not redistributing anything to them. You can't redistribute what was theirs to begin with.
 
They will pay off bills they already incurred.THAT is what we know they will do with it because it is what they did with the stimulus. Morever, I don't think encouraging the poor and middle class to spend more - is the way to help them build wealth. So, if they are infact just going to spend it, then I would rather not give it to them. That is quite the waste of artifically continuing to prop up this economy.

Because - anyone getting to keep more of their own money is not a redistribution. The money was theirs to being with - taking less of it is not redistributing anything to them. You can't redistribute what was theirs to begin with.

Money is fungible. Even if people used extra money to pay off bills, that would provide them with more to spend on goods and services (the money they would have otherwise used for bills). Of course, if you don't care whether there is more demand for goods and services, you don't. But economists do. It's very good for the economy.

And again, taxation policy by its very nature redistributes wealth. If a greater share of the tax burden is borne by the non-wealthy, they pay more in taxation than they otherwise would. If a greater share of the tax burden is borne by the wealthy, they pay more in taxation than they otherwise would. There is no distinction. Wealth is redistributed either way. Your ideology blinds you from seeing that.
 
Money is fungible. Even if people used extra money to pay off bills, that would provide them with more to spend on goods and services (the money they would have otherwise used for bills). Of course, if you don't care whether there is more demand for goods and services, you don't. But economists do. It's very good for the economy.

And again, taxation policy by its very nature redistributes wealth. If a greater share of the tax burden is borne by the non-wealthy, they pay more in taxation than they otherwise would. If a greater share of the tax burden is borne by the wealthy, they pay more in taxation than they otherwise would. There is no distinction. Wealth is redistributed either way. Your ideology blinds you from seeing that.

Yeah um... they weren't otherwise paying off those bills. THAT is the point. It didn't free up money to spend some other way.

And, that is why id didn't work. I do care - but I do not care to get damand by artificially goosing it by attempting to give more money at the consumer spending level. All it does is help cover up failed keynesian policies but that is why you guys like it so much. I want an economy that builds wealth with commerce - not just consumerism.

Again - you are well... wrong.

In your world taxation does that because you can not conceive of LESS money for Govt and LESS overall taxation.But, you see, I can. So, I do not buy all taxes are redistributive. TAXES in fact should have a direct purpose - or they shouldn't be taken. And, redistributing them is not one off those purposes. So, no, no way do you slice it - does taking less money from someone equal a redistribution to them. It was theirs. Letting someone keep more of what is there's is not giving them anything.
 
Yeah um... they weren't otherwise paying off those bills. THAT is the point. It didn't free up money to spend some other way.

And, that is why id didn't work. I do care - but I do not care to get damand by artificially goosing it by attempting to give more money at the consumer spending level. All it does is help cover up failed keynesian policies but that is why you guys like it so much. I want an economy that builds wealth with commerce - not just consumerism.

Again - you are well... wrong.

In your world taxation does that because you can not conceive of LESS money for Govt and LESS overall taxation.But, you see, I can. So, I do not buy all taxes are redistributive. TAXES in fact should have a direct purpose - or they shouldn't be taken. And, redistributing them is not one off those purposes. So, no, no way do you slice it - does taking less money from someone equal a redistribution to them. It was theirs. Letting someone keep more of what is there's is not giving them anything.

You spend a lot of time concocting positions I do not hold and arguing against them - strawmen. I'll ignore that and focus on your response to what I did say.

You stubbornly refuse to admit that poor and middle class people will buy more goods and services if they had more money. You even go so far as to say that bills paid with extra money would otherwise never get paid at all. I'm sure you know that's a daffy proposition - you're grasping at straws.

And you just ignore what I said about the redistributive effect of taxation no matter how it is structured. You spout platitudes instead and yammer about spendings levels, which is irrelevant to the question of adjusting the tax burdens of the wealthy vis-a-vis others. You seem to have nothing to say on the actual point I made.
 
Back
Top