New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Flat Tax Math

You spend a lot of time concocting positions I do not hold and arguing against them - strawmen. I'll ignore that and focus on your response to what I did say.

You stubbornly refuse to admit that poor and middle class people will buy more goods and services if they had more money. You even go so far as to say that bills paid with extra money would otherwise never get paid at all. I'm sure you know that's a daffy proposition - you're grasping at straws.

And you just ignore what I said about the redistributive effect of taxation no matter how it is structured. You spout platitudes instead and yammer about spendings levels, which is irrelevant to the question of adjusting the tax burdens of the wealthy vis-a-vis others. You seem to have nothing to say on the actual point I made.


Poor and middle class people often do not pay their bills which is why thier credit generally sucks. And, you can call it "daffy" all you like but when the last stimulus checks went out- the money did not find its way into cash being spent. It was saved for an emergency or to replenish emergency funds or paid off something that otherwise would not have been paid off.

I did not ignore. I have openly disagreed that all taxation is redistributive. It simply is not. Taxation - how it should be used is not re- distributive at all. How it is used is this country is - and is being used wrongly. So, no there should be no redistributive effect of taxation. That is exactly what I would like to get away from. We should each pay for an equal percentage portion of the services necessary to run the country. There should be no tax which comes back as social welfare, so there should be no redistribute effect of it.

You are not making any point. You are simply spouting talking points.
 
Poor and middle class people often do not pay their bills which is why thier credit generally sucks. And, you can call it "daffy" all you like but when the last stimulus checks went out- the money did not find its way into cash being spent. It was saved for an emergency or to replenish emergency funds or paid off something that otherwise would not have been paid off.

I did not ignore. I have openly disagreed that all taxation is redistributive. It simply is not. Taxation - how it should be used is not re- distributive at all. How it is used is this country is - and is being used wrongly. So, no there should be no redistributive effect of taxation. That is exactly what I would like to get away from. We should each pay for an equal percentage portion of the services necessary to run the country. There should be no tax which comes back as social welfare, so there should be no redistribute effect of it.

You are not making any point. You are simply spouting talking points.

You completely concocted the first paragraph and it's obviously false.

You have argued that tax hikes on the wealthy are redistributive, but not tax cuts. That's incoherent for the reasons I mentioned, and you ignore what I said. You drift off into yammering about how revenues are spent, which is obviously a different question than how the tax burden should be allocated as between the wealthy and the non-wealthy.
 
You completely concocted the first paragraph and it's obviously false.

You have argued that tax hikes on the wealthy are redistributive, but not tax cuts. That's incoherent for the reasons I mentioned, and you ignore what I said. You drift off into yammering about how revenues are spent, which is obviously a different question than how the tax burden should be allocated as between the wealthy and the non-wealthy.

I did not concoct it - here it is. Only 1/5 of people said they used their tax stimulus checks for spending. http://www.nber.org/digest/mar09/w14753.html
And, since being financially unstable leads to bad credit and bad credit is part of why people stay locked in poverty - yes, it is more likley you already had bad credit and weren't really worried about paying off that bill.

The reason cuts are no redistibutive, is that quite simply - they are nothing more taking less. Nothing came to you, you simply kept more of what you had.

And, since we are talking in a this thread - it is obvious I think w should have a flat tax where each person pays the same percentage. That is not "redistributing" anything. Nothing from you goes to me, and nothing from me, goes to you. Because we are each paying a proportionate share of the expenses. That way - if we don't like what Gov't costs - we can do something about it.
 
I did not concoct it - here it is. Only 1/5 of people said they used their tax stimulus checks for spending. http://www.nber.org/digest/mar09/w14753.html
And, since being financially unstable leads to bad credit and bad credit is part of why people stay locked in poverty - yes, it is more likley you already had bad credit and weren't really worried about paying off that bill.

The reason cuts are no redistibutive, is that quite simply - they are nothing more taking less. Nothing came to you, you simply kept more of what you had.

And, since we are talking in a this thread - it is obvious I think w should have a flat tax where each person pays the same percentage. That is not "redistributing" anything. Nothing from you goes to me, and nothing from me, goes to you. Because we are each paying a proportionate share of the expenses. That way - if we don't like what Gov't costs - we can do something about it.

Yikes.

First, that piece is about GWB's lame "stimulus" of 2008; not Obama's stimulus.

Second, it does not say what people did with that stimulus money; it says what people said they would do in the future.

Third, less than half said they would pay "mostly" debt with the money.

Your canard was that all such stimulus money was used to pay off debt - that it was not spent on good and services. That was false on the three counts I just mentioned.

And again - anytime tax policy is changed and the burden of taxation is shifted as between one class and another (which is always the case), wealth gets redistributed. That includes a shift to a flat tax (not that that will ever happen) - that change would redistribute wealth too. You refuse to accept the undeniable.
 
Yikes.

First, that piece is about GWB's lame "stimulus" of 2008; not Obama's stimulus.

Second, it does not say what people did with that stimulus money; it says what people said they would do in the future.

Third, less than half said they would pay "mostly" debt with the money.

Your canard was that all such stimulus money was used to pay off debt - that it was not spent on good and services. That was false on the three counts I just mentioned.

And again - anytime tax policy is changed and the burden of taxation is shifted as between one class and another (which is always the case), wealth gets redistributed. That includes a shift to a flat tax (not that that will ever happen) - that change would redistribute wealth too. You refuse to accept the undeniable.

Where did I mention "Obama's" Stimulus. You think magically the result of how people spent the money when they got it from Bush, versus Obama was somehow different. It was a poll - it was a description of the spending habits. If you think it was a rounding success and all that money went right back into consumer spending you produce the evidnece. There are plenty more articles like the one I posted which shows the spending habits - from the mouths of the people themselves.

I never said - all. You are treading very close to being a pain in the ass who makes up positions. So, knock it off, I won't put up with that shit.

The burden is s"shifted". I never argued it wasn't. So what, that is the point. To shift it to the lower income people so they can have some serious skin in the game and begin to vote to reduce the size and scope of Gov't rather than expanding it. That doesn't make it "redistributive" since you can't distribute back to me - something you never took from me in the first place. As opposed to the current tax policy which taxes from the rich and does actually give back in actual cash and direct benefits such as SNAP - to the poor.

Perhaps you are confused about who owns the wealth you act as if all the wealth we make is Gov'ts to do with as we please. But, if I make a million dollars, and the Gov't only taxes me 10% on that. They did not give me anything. I got no tax refund. I got no direct benefit - like SNAP or SS. I just paid less. Just because they now tax someone else more to make up for what they don't tax me again - distributed nothing to me. Taking a way less is not distributing anything to me. Presumably we are each paying for our share off the operating costs of Govt on a percentage basis.
 
A consumption based system is the only feasible system frankly. Poor people would painfully adjust to it but they would adjust ...frankly they need to anyway. The poverty you so much fear in their behalf is coming to them anyway by means of a deflated economy. Better that they face the consequences sooner and adjust to a better future. They are going to face the consequences one way or another. The idea that the current system can sustain itself is nonsense of the highest order.

Currently we use good tax money to support bad tax habits. It is horribly inefficient and the intrinsic value of the average tax dollar is destroyed by the parasitic process of collecting it and then wastefully spending it. Totally rediculous and talk about death spirals!

Tax Change is coming either by legislative process or by total crash....but it is coming.



JO

Why IS our currency so deflated, by the way? As for a consumption tax, it would only be on what we consume. People in much higher income brackets may spend from time to time, but they do not need to dedicate the bulk of their income on necessities like lower income brackets. Ergo, their tax obligation is disproportionately higher than higher income, whereby higher income groups can dedicate more of their income to 'saving' or 'investing'.
 
Where did I mention "Obama's" Stimulus. You think magically the result of how people spent the money when they got it from Bush, versus Obama was somehow different. It was a poll - it was a description of the spending habits. If you think it was a rounding success and all that money went right back into consumer spending you produce the evidnece. There are plenty more articles like the one I posted which shows the spending habits - from the mouths of the people themselves.

I never said - all. You are treading very close to being a pain in the ass who makes up positions. So, knock it off, I won't put up with that shit.

The burden is s"shifted". I never argued it wasn't. So what, that is the point. To shift it to the lower income people so they can have some serious skin in the game and begin to vote to reduce the size and scope of Gov't rather than expanding it. That doesn't make it "redistributive" since you can't distribute back to me - something you never took from me in the first place. As opposed to the current tax policy which taxes from the rich and does actually give back in actual cash and direct benefits such as SNAP - to the poor.

Perhaps you are confused about who owns the wealth you act as if all the wealth we make is Gov'ts to do with as we please. But, if I make a million dollars, and the Gov't only taxes me 10% on that. They did not give me anything. I got no tax refund. I got no direct benefit - like SNAP or SS. I just paid less. Just because they now tax someone else more to make up for what they don't tax me again - distributed nothing to me. Taking a way less is not distributing anything to me. Presumably we are each paying for our share off the operating costs of Govt on a percentage basis.

Your just babbling and making shit up now. I busted you on your whopper for all three reasons I laid out above. You have no apparent interest in an honest discussion. You also like to issue threats when the debate doesn't go your way. All very tedious.
 
Your just babbling and making shit up now. I busted you on your whopper for all three reasons I laid out above. You have no apparent interest in an honest discussion. You also like to issue threats when the debate doesn't go your way. All very tedious.

You're expecting logic from the group who still buys into 'trickle down economics' or that tax hikes (especially huge ones) create jobs.

And maybe I have a comprehension problem, but where and how did Social Security fit into her explanation?
 
Where did I mention "Obama's" Stimulus. You think magically the result of how people spent the money when they got it from Bush, versus Obama was somehow different. It was a poll - it was a description of the spending habits. If you think it was a rounding success and all that money went right back into consumer spending you produce the evidnece. There are plenty more articles like the one I posted which shows the spending habits - from the mouths of the people themselves.

I never said - all. You are treading very close to being a pain in the ass who makes up positions. So, knock it off, I won't put up with that shit.

The burden is s"shifted". I never argued it wasn't. So what, that is the point. To shift it to the lower income people so they can have some serious skin in the game and begin to vote to reduce the size and scope of Gov't rather than expanding it. That doesn't make it "redistributive" since you can't distribute back to me - something you never took from me in the first place. As opposed to the current tax policy which taxes from the rich and does actually give back in actual cash and direct benefits such as SNAP - to the poor.

Perhaps you are confused about who owns the wealth you act as if all the wealth we make is Gov'ts to do with as we please. But, if I make a million dollars, and the Gov't only taxes me 10% on that. They did not give me anything. I got no tax refund. I got no direct benefit - like SNAP or SS. I just paid less. Just because they now tax someone else more to make up for what they don't tax me again - distributed nothing to me. Taking a way less is not distributing anything to me. Presumably we are each paying for our share off the operating costs of Govt on a percentage basis.

Exactly! Just be thankful they don't take it all...

 
Your just babbling and making shit up now. I busted you on your whopper for all three reasons I laid out above. You have no apparent interest in an honest discussion. You also like to issue threats when the debate doesn't go your way. All very tedious.

You busted nothing. I offered evidence. You offered nothing. As usual, when you lose you devolve to snide personal insults. But, I will agree, discussing anything with you - is tedious. Generally why I don't bother.
 
Exactly! Just be thankful they don't take it all...



Yeah, I love the arguments too- you were subsidized by not being taxed on your health insurance from your employer. NEWSFLASH - not taxing me on something - is not a subsidy. You didn't give me anything that wasn't mine, already.
 
You busted nothing. I offered evidence. You offered nothing. As usual, when you lose you devolve to snide personal insults. But, I will agree, discussing anything with you - is tedious. Generally why I don't bother.

Care to retract this claim?

And, you may see it that way, but you would be wrong. Reversing it - most likely will result in what happened a few years ago when the stimulus checks went out - people use them to pay off the bills they have already incurred and don't spend hardly any new money.

Care to retract the claim that some poll you posted as to what people said they would do if/when they got stimulus checks proves what they did with the money after they got their checks?

Care to retract the claim that, even as to any stimulus amounts used to pay bills, that would not free up other money to be used to buy goods and services, money being fungible?
 
Care to retract this claim?

And, you may see it that way, but you would be wrong. Reversing it - most likely will result in what happened a few years ago when the stimulus checks went out - people use them to pay off the bills they have already incurred and don't spend hardly any new money.

Care to retract the claim that some poll you posted as to what people said they would do if/when they got stimulus checks proves what they did with the money after they got their checks?

Care to retract the claim that, even as to any stimulus amounts used to pay bills, that would not free up other money to be used to buy goods and services, money being fungible?

Why would I "retract' the claim that what people said they would do with the money was not what they did with the money - in the absence of conflicting testimony and evidence?

Why would I retract a claim that I didn't make. I said that the money did not find its way into the economy for the purchase of consumer products. Besides which even if it did find its way in, by the time it passes through many hands the effect of "stimulating" it was negligble The fact that more money is in the overall economy - is not necessarily a "good thing" even though it gets in there. A bigger GDP is not necessarily better.
 
its only a "crippling tax hike" for the poor if someone sets the minimum income level very low.

what is the proposed minimum income that the tax hits?

the founding fathers apparently believed that almost everyone - rich and poor - should have some skin in the game, and pay something to the upkeep of their nation in exchange for its benefits.

they likely would be horrified at the present situation with so many people not paying tax, except for social security which is in danger of insolvency anwyay
Once again I have to point out that everyone has "skin" in the game. The poor don't pay Federal income taxes, but do pay a huge amount of their income in the other taxes and fess like sales taxes, state income taxes, FICA and Medicare taxes, property taxes, driver's licenses and car registration fees, i.e. taxes.
The other thing you mentioned about Social Security is wrong. The system is at least a trillion dollars in the black and with a little adjustment could be solvent for fifty years. The problem is that our parties, both Dems and GOP, have "borrowed" money from Social Security program and left it with IOU's. Now they tell us they can't afford the system after robbing it blind.
 
Care to retract this claim?

And, you may see it that way, but you would be wrong. Reversing it - most likely will result in what happened a few years ago when the stimulus checks went out - people use them to pay off the bills they have already incurred and don't spend hardly any new money.

Care to retract the claim that some poll you posted as to what people said they would do if/when they got stimulus checks proves what they did with the money after they got their checks?

Care to retract the claim that, even as to any stimulus amounts used to pay bills, that would not free up other money to be used to buy goods and services, money being fungible?

Show us the evidence that ANY of the $10 trillion in "stimulus" on Obama's watch has done ANYTHING to "fix" the REAL economy (not the stock market).
 
Once again I have to point out that everyone has "skin" in the game. The poor don't pay Federal income taxes, but do pay a huge amount of their income in the other taxes and fess like sales taxes, state income taxes, FICA and Medicare taxes, property taxes, driver's licenses and car registration fees, i.e. taxes.
The other thing you mentioned about Social Security is wrong. The system is at least a trillion dollars in the black and with a little adjustment could be solvent for fifty years. The problem is that our parties, both Dems and GOP, have "borrowed" money from Social Security program and left it with IOU's. Now they tell us they can't afford the system after robbing it blind.

Yes, which means they could not care less about how big the bureaucracy gets and how bloated the budgets are, because they only pay (federal) taxes for the SS & MC benefits that they will receive in their old age that will very likely exceed the value of the taxes they paid.
 
Show us the evidence that ANY of the $10 trillion in "stimulus" on Obama's watch has done ANYTHING to "fix" the REAL economy (not the stock market).

His stimulus was obviously not $10 trillion, but let's skip that clumsy lie.

The evidence you asked for:

60 months in a row of economic growth and jobs growth, replacing the GWB era nightmare of 750,000 job losses per month, and economic retraction at an annualized clip of almost 10%.
 
I'm not sure upon what you base that, but I'd like to suggest you think again. This chart:

http://mercatus.org/sites/default/files/tax-revenue-path-plus-top-marginal-rates-chart-original.jpg

Says you are wrong...

They really believe that all they need to do to make prosperity available to all is kill the wealthy..... WOW..... I did not realize how deep their ignorance was until now.

These guys actually think tht this is a zero sum game and that the fixed amount of wealth is all stored up one end of the spectrum......Now I see why they are wailing and hollering all the time about the wealthy....they think the wealthy have their money.

Bwahahahahahahahah....that's a total hoot.

JO
 
His stimulus was obviously not $10 trillion, but let's skip that clumsy lie.

The evidence you asked for:

60 months in a row of economic growth and jobs growth, replacing the GWB era nightmare of 750,000 job losses per month, and economic retraction at an annualized clip of almost 10%.

$4.5 trillion added to Fed balance sheet and $5.5 trillion in deficit spending since Obama was elected (my guess is that the true numbers for both are actually a little higher - but who's counting?).

GDP "growth:"

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-Sf9iVEkYCVc/VM1FqtgDfQI/AAAAAAAAiJw/uRplbdS7jXs/s1600/GDPLabor2.PNG

2% is the new 4%!

Employment:

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-JKLGtMzYa...sa-employment-levels-2006-01-thru-2014-07.png

Six years to get back to where we were before the recession.

http://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/charts/employment/LFPR-25-54-since-1990.gif

Working age Americans out of the workforce have not been able to return at the levels we enjoyed before Bushbama.

Most recent economic growth indicator:

https://www.frbatlanta.org/cqer/researchcq/gdpnow.cfm

ZERO!

What did we waste that $10 trillion on, anyway?
 
Back
Top