New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Flat Tax Math

Rand Paul is advocating moving to a single flat tax, as opposed to a graduated income tax. He is also advocating a move that would make it so those who live off unearned investment income get a free ride at the expense of those of us who do productive labor.

It's worth taking a look at the math behind this, and what it would mean to most people. Currently the average effective federal tax rate is around 17.6%.

http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Docid=456

Therefore, in order to be revenue neutral, a new tax system would also have to have an average effective federal tax rate of around 17.6% (probably around a 25% nominal flat tax, with minimal exemptions and some allowance for tax dodging and other collections issues). So, if it was flat, here's what would happen to the effective tax rate of each of the following income percentiles:

0-20th: +15.7
21-40th: +10.6
41-60th: +6.4
61-80th: +2.4
81-90th: -1.0
91-95th: -3.5
96-99th: -6.7
Top 1%: -11.4

If you're lower class, it's a crippling tax hike, which would either force a radical expansion of social spending or would result in mass starvation and homelessness. If you're middle class, it's still a big tax hike. For those right in the middle, they'll be handing Uncle Sam $1.57, under the new system, for every $1 they currently hand him. Even the upper-middle class will be getting hosed.

If you're lower-upper-class, it's a small tax cut, while for those in the upper reaches, it becomes a more significant cut. And for the very richest, it's a gigantic cut. In fact, those numbers don't do justice to just how much a tax scheme like Paul's would favor the wealthy, since he couples it with an elimination of taxes on investment income, the lion's share of which is "earned" by the rich.

If you're cutting out the $100 billion or so of capital gains tax revenues, plus around $20 billion in estate and gift taxes (another sweetheart deal from Paul to the wealthy), and who knows how much more in interest and dividends taxes, and you want revenue neutrality, you're going to need to hike taxes on the working classes even more than the figures above indicate. You wind up with an effective income tax hike on over 90% of Americans.

For the ultra-rich, the Paul tax cut would be truly epic. Take Mitt Romney, for example. Using the numbers he filed in 2012, when he earned $13.7 million, only $200,000 of which was for actual labor (the rest being investment income), Romney would pay an effective tax rate of less than 0.3% -- down from an already shockingly low 14.1%. So, for him it would be a reduction of 13.8 points, and he'd pay less, not just as a rate but even in dollar terms, than millions of hard-working professionals who earn a fraction what he does. For Romney, it means approximately $1.9 million more in his pocket per year. I'm sure that'll help finance the next dancing horse or car elevator.

It's not hard to get why super-rich people love the idea of a flat tax. It's just not clear why anyone else does.

Just to clarify, Rand Paul doesn't propose a 17.6% rate. His proposal is 17%, and he allows for various exemptions. However, if you're starting out below the current 17.6% effective rate, just for the nominal rate, and allowing exemptions, then the effective rate will wind up far below the current effective rate, meaning a massive revenue shortfall and a gigantic increase in deficits. My math is for a revenue-neutral tax cut, not one that would drive the country into financial ruin like Paul's. Paul's own campaign admits his plan would cut revenues by $700 billion per year. So, it's a fairy-tale tax scheme based on the idea that we can radically slash federal spending even as we hike the tax bill for the vast majority of Americans, all to make the wealthy few even richer.

And as horribly as this scheme would work right from the start, it would get even worse with time. Given the free ride for investment income, employers would soon realize that they can hire people cheaper if they make their incomes tax-free by disguising it as investment income rather than salaries and wages. We already see some of that today, with senior execs and hedge fund managers getting a big part of their pay disguised in those ways to take advantage of lower taxes on investment income, but there's little incentive to do that for those who aren't very rich today, since their income tax rates aren't appreciably higher (and are sometimes lower) than rates on investment income. But if you have a 0% rate on investment income, the incentive will be there to structure everyone's compensation in such a way as to characterize as much as possible as investment income. For example, give all employees special "preferred stock" that pays most of their incomes as "dividends," and leave them with only a minimum-wage income taxable at income tax rates. And that will further crater revenues, requiring still higher tax rates on those still paying income taxes. It's a death spiral that anyone could see coming.

How are your "unearned" investments doing?
 
So when you called for increasing taxes on the non-wealthy above, that means you want to lower their taxes and hike taxes on the wealthy?

You doing comedy now?

;-)

When the Nazi left is done strip mining the wealth from the upper middle class, it wont be the top .01% who will be next, but the lower middle classes.
 
So when you called for increasing taxes on the non-wealthy above, that means you want to lower their taxes and hike taxes on the wealthy?

You doing comedy now?

;-)

No, can you not read? We need to increase taxes to pay for all the big government the progressive administration(s) of Bushbama have added. I would increase taxes on the wealthy quite a lot, keep the middle class even (as they already pay the bulk of income taxes), and raise taxes on the non-wealthy just a bit (so they have some skin in the game). After all, we're all in this together.
 
No, can you not read? We need to increase taxes to pay for all the big government the progressive administration(s) of Bushbama have added. I would increase taxes on the wealthy quite a lot, keep the middle class even (as they already pay the bulk of income taxes), and raise taxes on the non-wealthy just a bit (so they have some skin in the game). After all, we're all in this together.

Hmm...not very "supply side" of you, but fair enough.

Your plan is to hike the taxes of both the wealthy and the working poor, and that would shrink the wealth gap?
 
You alternate posts carping about the growth in the wealth gap with posts carping about how the wealthy have been asked to bear too great a portion of the income tax burden. The usual inconsistency and incoherence.

And I'm sure you know that, all forms of taxation included, the poor and middle class pay a very large percentage of their income in taxes. The mega wealthy, like Steve Forbes, snicker when they see the GOP rabble supporting their flat tax hooey - they would love another huge tax cut!

;-)

Frankly bugs you cannot fix the gap with taxation. In fact you can't do anything about the wealthy....the reason that they are wealthy is because they have already found a way to avoid being taxed into poverty and they will always find a way as long as your preferred form of government....which is giving " Free shit " to potential voters exists. It is a self propagaging systemic disease which actually depends on that wealth gap to keep going. If the Wealth gap were to shrink the " Free shit " crowd would suddenly become more fiscally aware and responsible for their decisions....that would immediately spell the end of the left.

Just telling you the truth here.

JO
 
Hmm...not very "supply side" of you, but fair enough.

Your plan is to hike the taxes of both the wealthy and the working poor, and that would shrink the wealth gap?

Hey Bugs, you were all aboard subsidizing the wealthy with TARP/QE liquidity stimulus bailouts. Well guess what, you WON! And today the rich have never been richer while the middle class has never been poorer.
 
Hmm...not very "supply side" of you, but fair enough.

Your plan is to hike the taxes of both the wealthy and the working poor, and that would shrink the wealth gap?

Did it shrink during Clinton's "era of big government is over" era? Median incomes rose for much of his time in office so I think the answer is yes.

The simple fact that you progressives can't seem to get through your thick skulls is that the more big government spends (even on welfare) the more wealthy the wealthy seem to get.
 
Hey Bugs, you were all aboard subsidizing the wealthy with TARP/QE liquidity stimulus bailouts. Well guess what, you WON! And today the rich have never been richer while the middle class has never been poorer.

Exactly and I'd love to see a correlation between the amount of welfare spending and the share price of Walmart!
 
Exactly and I'd love to see a correlation between the amount of welfare spending and the share price of Walmart!

The last I saw one third of all Walmart sales came from EBT cards.

BTW: Those EBT cards are managed by JP Morgan & Chase, who collects almost 3% profit off every welfare dollar.

HOPE/CHANGE

EDIT: I would like to see how much Federal Govt Debt is held in proxy by the 7th largest shareholder of the Federal Reserve (JPM&C) but that information is censored under Homeland Security and the Patriot Act security provisions.
 
Frankly bugs you cannot fix the gap with taxation. In fact you can't do anything about the wealthy....the reason that they are wealthy is because they have already found a way to avoid being taxed into poverty and they will always find a way as long as your preferred form of government....which is giving " Free shit " to potential voters exists. It is a self propagaging systemic disease which actually depends on that wealth gap to keep going. If the Wealth gap were to shrink the " Free shit " crowd would suddenly become more fiscally aware and responsible for their decisions....that would immediately spell the end of the left.

Just telling you the truth here.

JO

Absurd. You says the wealthy can't be required to pay a larger share of the tax load because they wiggle out of paying taxes. Under current tax laws they do, but it's ridiculous to assert that new tax laws could not put an end to that. Hike their rates, eliminate the loopholes and...Voila! Task accomplished.
 
No, can you not read? We need to increase taxes to pay for all the big government the progressive administration(s) of Bushbama have added. I would increase taxes on the wealthy quite a lot, keep the middle class even (as they already pay the bulk of income taxes), and raise taxes on the non-wealthy just a bit (so they have some skin in the game). After all, we're all in this together.

He can read just fine...it's his job to " Sculpt " your post into something that it is not so that it can be prepared for more effective atttack. This is not a conversation for them its an experiment. I swear these guys come here to hone and practice before they go back to their talking points meetings with instructions on how to twist the statements of political opponents.

JO
 
Absurd. You says the wealthy can't be required to pay a larger share of the tax load because they wiggle out of paying taxes. Under current tax laws they do, but it's ridiculous to assert that new tax laws could not put an end to that. Hike their rates, eliminate the loopholes and...Voila! Task accomplished.

No...I am saying that you can shrink the gap with taxes....not gonna happen. It will only happen from the othe direction.

JO
 
Absurd. You says the wealthy can't be required to pay a larger share of the tax load because they wiggle out of paying taxes. Under current tax laws they do, but it's ridiculous to assert that new tax laws could not put an end to that. Hike their rates, eliminate the loopholes and...Voila! Task accomplished.

I'm not sure upon what you base that, but I'd like to suggest you think again. This chart:

http://mercatus.org/sites/default/files/tax-revenue-path-plus-top-marginal-rates-chart-original.jpg

Says you are wrong...
 
Did it shrink during Clinton's "era of big government is over" era? Median incomes rose for much of his time in office so I think the answer is yes.

The simple fact that you progressives can't seem to get through your thick skulls is that the more big government spends (even on welfare) the more wealthy the wealthy seem to get.

It did not. The wealthy did fabulously well during the Clinton era. All classes did, but the wealthy started with more wealth, so the gap grew despite all classes doing better.

Back to the topic - shifting more of the tax load to the wealthy would obviously shrink the gap. Instead, you propose slashing welfare, further increasing the impoverishment of the poor. That's daffy.
 
It did not. The wealthy did fabulously well during the Clinton era. All classes did, but the wealthy started with more wealth, so the gap grew despite all classes doing better.

Back to the topic - shifting more of the tax load to the wealthy would obviously shrink the gap. Instead, you propose slashing welfare, further increasing the impoverishment of the poor. That's daffy.

I'd like to do exactly that. I don't recall saying anything about "slashing" anyting. I merely suggested we stop increasing government spending beyond our ability to pay for it.
 
I'd like to do exactly that. I don't recall saying anything about "slashing" anyting. I merely suggested we stop increasing government spending beyond our ability to pay for it.

Then you want to cap welfare spending, rather than cutting it? You figure that will reduce the wealth gap?
 
You know my rule - you must make a point if you want me to respond. Supporting a point with a link is fine.

Hahaha! You don't make the rules around here. The point in that chart is obvious. No matter what the marginal income tax rate was the government collected about the same percent of GDP. So why on earth do you pointy headed progressives keep suggesting that the outcome of changing marginal rates does anything to increase tax take? Obviously (from that chart) the only way to increase tax revenue is to find a tax policy that best supports economic growth.
 
He can read just fine...it's his job to " Sculpt " your post into something that it is not so that it can be prepared for more effective atttack. This is not a conversation for them its an experiment. I swear these guys come here to hone and practice before they go back to their talking points meetings with instructions on how to twist the statements of political opponents.

JO

You should address the issues more, and ditto less.
 
Back
Top